Paul's Live From New York Pizza
4.6(5k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(5k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
My family and I have been dedicated to serving NewYork style pizza in Humboldt county since 1994. We pride our self in creating a unique product that our east coast roots can pass on to the people of …
Full Menu
11:30 am - 8:25 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
18" Traditional New York Pizza
$35.98+
•100% (6)
18" Cheese Pizza
$35.99
•95% (95)
#2 Most liked
Sicilian Crust Cheese Pizza
$41.99
The 'Roni Special
$16.19+
•92% (57)
14" Cheese Pizza
$23.99
•93% (118)
#1 Most liked
14" Traditional New York Pizza
$23.98+
•100% (6)
Reviews5k+ ratings • 70+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
P
Patrick B
5 contributionsLoved
• 7/28/26The pizza is delicious fresh they make the sausage in the house, so its bettet than anywhere else in humboldt. The Meatballs (3) in Marinara with Romano & Parsley are huge and a great appetizer. A true taste of New York the main thing I always miss is the food and they nail it. Wish they would start making cheesecake also then they'd just be perfect. 😉
J
John T
4 contributionsDidn't like
• 5/3/26Pizza was not fully cooked, I even ordered it well done. New York combo had no olives, skimpy on rest of toppings only 2 pepperoni per slice. Dough didn't rise or puff up. Paid $51.59 for premium pizza it was mediocre at best. Live from new York is not consistent itis hit or miss, two weeks ago it was good no problems. This week it was waste of money, I wish I got dutchys they are always consistent.
R
Rachelle G
1 contributionsLoved
• 1/10/22Usually go for a pizza but was blown away by the calzone and baked ziti. Wow meatballs taste amazing, the cheese in the calzone I think it's ricotta so good. Highly recommend salad with house dressing.
C
Connor C
1 contributionsDidn't like
• 12/7/25The Margherita pizza was good - would order again.
Caesar salad was small, expensive, and tasted bad - rating 2/10.
L
Lexx C
Local Expert • 24 contributionsLiked
• 5/4/26It was ok. I wouldn't say I disliked it nor loved it. It was just ok. Pizza doesn't look anything like the photos I viewed. There was too much cheese and overall was very mediocrely executed. It didn't hit the mark. I will say it is a good value for the size. The Small Dinner Salad was not bad. It was fresh. I'd probably try elsewhere next time.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Hero Sandwiches
Served with french fries. OnionRings or Small Dinner Salad with an upcharge...
Appetizers
Salads
Served with a dinner bread.
On the Side
On the Side...
Garlic Bread & Garlic Knots
Entrees & Pasta
Choice of salad or garlic bread.
Pizza (Specialty Combinations)
Pizza Half and Half (Specialty Combinations)
Pizza (Choose Your Items)
Live From New York Pizza
Double-Crusted Pizzas
Wings & Tenders
Pizza Rolls
Large Calzone
Mozzarella, Ricotta, & Marinara on the side. With your choice of toppings...