4.7(2k+)•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
4.7(2k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Since 1994, my family and I have dedicated ourselves to serving New York style pizza throughout Humboldt County. We take satisfaction in developing a one-of-a-kind product that our east coast roots ca…
Full Menu
11:30 am - 8:30 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
New York Combo
$25.49+
•100% (25)
'Roni Special
$21.89+
•100% (18)
18" Traditional Cheese Pizza
$33.38
•94% (74)
#2 Most liked
The Chicken Club
$24.29+
14" Traditional Cheese Pizza
$27.08
•98% (91)
#1 Most liked
The Joe Namath
$23.09+
Reviews2k+ ratings • 30+ public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
D
debbie and scott h
Emerging Expert • 8 contributionsLoved
• 10/1/24The salad was amazing but they are not lying when they said Large Dinner Salad! I got it for myself for lunch and ended up eating it all day and still didn't eat all of it, barely half. definitely worth my money but getting a small next time XD
P
Phyllis P
Local Expert • 106 contributionsLiked
• 2/23/26I cannot express enough how flavorful & delicious their pizza is. I had the Garden of Eden which is so delectable 😋😋 Perfect crust, creamy cheeses, spinach & tomates... out of this world! The Small Dinner Salad was also fresh & a delicious medley mix of flavors & crispy! So yummy!! 😋😋 Sorry no pics,... next time.
L
Lauren A
Emerging Expert • 15 contributionsLoved
• 12/10/21Enjoyed the HUGE, delicious calzon, but it's that side of tomato sauce they provided that's making my mouth water.
A
Addie D
1 contributionsDidn't like
• 6/14/25We ordered the Brooklyn. They must have run out of spinach because our normally loaded pie barely had any spinach at all. I opened one slice & there was literally one spinach leaf. One piece had none! The outside crust normally had garlic toasted on it & there was none. I sure hope this isnt their new recipe because it's so disappointing.
M
Mary T
8 contributionsLiked
• 4/7/25We were disappointed because the pizza was just lukewarm and the "large" dinner salad was quite a bit smaller than usual. We usually love their food, but weren't happy with it this time. Door Dash dropped the ball on communication after I ordered, too. We preordered online before they were open, but I think we were down a ways on their delivery list. Next time we will just pick our order up.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Heroes
All Heroes come w/ French Fries. (Onion Rings or a Small Dinner Salad may be substituted for an upcharge)
Specialty Pizzas
Paul's Live From New York Pizza
Dinners
All Dinners are served w/ either a small dinner salad, garlic bread, or dinner breads...
Pizza
Traditional New York Thin, Sicilian, and Gluten-Free
Double-Crusted Specialty Pizzas
Paul's Live From New York Pizza
