Peace Pie began Thanksgiving night 2010, over a delicious batch of pie filling and a forgotten pie crust. Jerry Klause, founder and creator, baked the pie filling and two giant shortbread cookies, the…
Both the Cookie Dough and PB Pretzel were delicious. Fairly big ice cream sandwiches with plenty of filling! Well worth it
B
Briana H
2 contributions
Loved
• 2/3/23
• DoorDash order
Caramel Coffee Toffee & Peanut Butter Brownie are incredible! Best ice cream ever and always hits the spot!
V
Veronica D
9 contributions
Liked
• 1 day ago
• DoorDash order
So far everything looked good. The only thing I didn't appreciate is I ordered six piece pies and only two of them I could tell what I ordered because of the color of the ice cream The other ones I don't know what flavor it is because they're not labeled other than that I'm sure we'll figure it out and the one was delicious Jersey devil
M
Manny D
1 contributions
Loved
• 3/28/24
• DoorDash order
I've been coming to Cape May all my life and walked by this place a million times. However, I finally took the plunge and WOW. This will be a stop every time I'm down here, which is often.
The S'mores - Regular Price was delicious and it was tough not to eat the Boston Cream Pie that I bought to put in the freezer for later on.
The ice cream is the perfect consistency and the cookie is just the right hardness to not make this a mess of an eating experience. Definitely a must have!
C
Crystal C
30 contributions
Loved
• 11/16/25
• DoorDash order
This is decadently delicious. I treat myself to a Coffee Toffee whenever I'm in Cape May.
