First time trying Penzo's! Native New Yorker here! I had the Penzo pesto pizza and a cannoli. Both exceeded my expectations! Lots of fresh toppings on the pizza, and the cannoli tasted like my Gram's. New favorite dinner spot! Thanks for an awesome meal!
D
Daae J
1 contributions
Loved
• 1/28/26
• DoorDash order
One of the best Neapolitan pizza joints one can find around, along with Pizzeria Verita! The dough has right airy chewiness, the tomato sauce good sourness(I change the base sauce from garlic oil to red), and the generous portion of flavorful wild mushrooms. I usually add pineapple toppings to give a bit more tart and sweet flavors. It has become my weekly staple.
C
Cara J
Local Expert • 25 contributions
Liked
• 5/3/26
• DoorDash order
Delicious GLUTEN-FREE 10" Custom Pizza! The gluten free crust was crunchy and yummy which is hard to find. I did need to heat it up a bit when it arrived but very good and very fresh and portion size is good for the cost!
B
Brady D
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/22/26
• DoorDash order
Pizza was not cooked all the way and very bland. Alot of crust, not alot of pie. Very small pie. Not worth the price. Cannolis were good and worth the price.
M
Madeline W
10 contributions
Liked
• 6/20/24
• DoorDash order
I'm glad there's finally another place to order from and this place is pretty good, though prices are random. A delicious small pizza full of ingredients is like $11 (great deal) while a slightly larger pizza with 3 ingredients is like $25. For our larger one, they left off one of the 3 ingredients that is arguably the most important part - the meat. It also says "cheese pizza" when you customize it, insinuating you're choosing ingredients in addition to a basic cheese pizza, but no mozzarella was included. Just sauce and the 3 chosen ingredients on top. It also seemed like they used the same amount of dough as the smaller pizzas because it was much thinner than the individual pizza. Not the biggest deal but combining it all is frustrating when you're spending so much . Anyway - the small menu-designed pizzas are great, Battered Artichokes great but overpriced, and I'll probably avoid larger or any custom pizzas in the future.
