excellent homemade pies. they bring back memories of Sunday dinners at my great-grandmother's house-level of good and authenticity. I have gotten every chocolate pie offering they have-and they are all first rate. so was the brown butter honey pecan. also both the cherry crumb and the sour cherry pies are a total delight. Old fashioned blue ribbon at the state fair kind of delicious pies. aargh-i want one right now!
R
Room 7
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Loved
• 1/21/26
• DoorDash order
The first pie in NYC that really is homemade pie, it is not like store bought quality where the crust is thick like cookie, these pies from Pete are thin, but crunchy, the toppings are soft, not too sweet like most dessert in NYC. One improvement for them is please add more food scent into it, how is chocolate doesn't smell like either milk or dark chocolate?
J
Juliann L
8 contributions
Loved
• 4/3/22
• DoorDash order
My new go-to spot! This place makes excellent quality desserts. The lavish chocolate cream pie, key lime pie, and coconut custard pie are incredible - clearly made with quality ingredients and a lot of attention to detail.
A
Amy B
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
Loved
• 12/11/22
• DoorDash order
Petee's is just perfect for pies! I often get the Key Lime Slice and it is consistently good. So nice that they offer both lemon and lime. Cherry Crumb Slice has some nice spices in the filling. My first time ordering the Eggnog Cheesecake Slice and let me say that it was very memorable! Petee's does a really good job with their crumb crusts, in general. The cheesecake texture was just divine (firm, yet creamy) and the flavor of the cheesecake was really scrumptious (althought I didn't really discern eggnog flavor).
P
Precious C
8 contributions
Loved
• 10/3/22
• DoorDash order
Literally one of the best delivery meals I've have hands down in decades! The garlic beef shank pie was literally all meat from end to end. Savory and with a melt in your mouth crust ugh pure magic! Chocolate pie is just as it's name describes it lavish velvety and works so well with that light yet buttery crust. Will definitely be ordering again! Trust me you will not want to pass on this! Bravo team bravo!
