I've been on the hunt for decent NY-Style pizza in the area for ages, and it has FINALLY arrived. We did the Sausage Was the Case, added garlic, double pepperoni & olives on one half and it was out of this world. We also ordered the meatballs which came with garlic knots. Both items so very simple, but so exquisitely done. May seem hyperbolic, but I stand by it! This is now my new favorite pizza joint!
M
Marcus G
4 contributions
12/9/23
• DoorDash order
Pizza once again, some of the best I've had. Meatballs were a great side. Now, I have to say, as simple as the salad is, I ask one thing, please bottle and sell that salad dressing separately! So good. Love this place for our pizza Fridays.
L
Lance H
2 contributions
4/28/25
• DoorDash order
I track down Vodka pizza especially thin crust or NY style vodka pizzas. This was not that. I wouldnt even take the time to write down this below average review BUT for $60+ dollar Pizza !!!! A Very average pepperoni pizza (also above average Salty) with room temp vodka sauce on top ?
(3.5 out of 10)
Prince street pizza has a really proper vodka sauce pizza. Same exact layout & So good that the next day it's even more mind blowing like most great italian food. But, for 50% less money.. Thats whats Truly Crazy. how expensive this Pizza was, so I had high expectations & teamed up with Yelp reviews i was like "it should be worth 2 days of pizza $60+ (1 pizza) Ding Dong:.. An average pepperoni pizza arrives, but with below average "on top" vodka style sauce. I really wanted to like it. Super salty right off the bite.. 2 slices in and between the mediocre sauce splashed on top super salty pepperoni & average pizza the rest is headed into the trash bin. Good Lesson ($) when done right and the flavors all work together as well as compliment. Vs seeminly a pepperoni pizza with some low quality vodka sauce on top. (3.5 out of 10)
J
Jamyson H
2 contributions
12/29/23
• DoorDash order
Amazing pizza and atmosphere. The dough is delicious and perfectly baked. Good amount of cheese and delicious sauce. Highly recommend.
M
Marcus G
4 contributions
6/28/25
• DoorDash order
Team, been a customer for awhile, and I have to to say overall, pizza is good. I want to share however, I feel like quality is dropping. Less sauce, less cheese, less ingredients. Taste is still great because you use quality ingredients, but I feel like overall quality is slipping. I could be wrong. But a $40 pie has to be perfect, every time, or I'll just go somewhere else. I feel like your stuck, fast nickels or slow quarters. Please, take a look at the quality, I could be wrong, probably not. Not going anywhere else, yet..... make sure of it!
