Always good. We love the Tenderloin Sliders & starter Tomato Bruschetta. Desserts are delicious my husband adores his Caramelized Cheesecake !
Anytime we have an issue PINESTRIPES manager always helps us and they are so fast with our order.
K
Karena T
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
Liked
• 3/25/26
• DoorDash order
The Seafood Mac and Cheese travels surprisingly well. INCREDIBLY cheesy and solidly satisfying Mac & Cheese with a decent amount of seafood in it - 1 serving is enough for 2 meals, in my opinion.
Their Brussels Sprouts are also among my favorite iterations of the dish - both sweet and savory, cooked on the softer side without being utterly mushy, with a generous drenching of the soy sauce-based dressing that makes it so yummy.
I think I prefer the Gnocchi & Vodka Sauce in the restaurant, but I couldn't tell you why - possibly the gnocchi gets a little soggier during travel? Usually, it's very satisfying to split with a family.
The only disappointing dish I can report is the side of Baked Mac & Cheese - really flavorless, especially compared to the super cheesy, flavorful Seafood Mac and Cheese. I ended up adding a lot of Everything But the Bagel seasoning and some additional cheese of my own to make it flavorful enough to eat.
H
Hannah D
Local Expert • 70 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/30/25
• DoorDash order
For an $18 dollars Caesar Salad with aside of steak and they gave you 4 pieces in which I didn't ask them to cut is ridiculous !! Will never order salad from this place again . The super salad was better because my salmon was on the side .
K
Karena T
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
Liked
• 3/17/26
• DoorDash order
The Seafood Mac & Cheese is decadent. If you're looking for a safisfyingly cheesy mac & cheese that's augmented by seafood, this is the way to go - delicious even after delivery or reheating the leftovers!
The Chicken & Goat Cheese Pasta is also yummy - best fresh from the restaurant; doesn't reheat as well, unfortunately.
Portion sizes are generous. Would definitely order the Seafood Mac & Cheese again! And the Brussels Sprouts are *always* a nice addition to any meal from Pinstripes. Sweet, savory, and cooked just enough.
C
Charlotte J
10 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/12/23
• DoorDash order
The Spaghetti & Meatballs and Purely Pistachio Gelato were delicious as usual... we order regularly ... but the crispy strips on my Signature Chop Salad were stale and there weren't nearly as many olives and figs as there usually are. This is my favorite salad and it was disappointing.
