Deano Zahakis, the founder of Pizza Casbah, migrated from his homeland of Long Island, New York to Fort Collins, Colorado in 1999. Deano opened Pizza Casbah just two doors down from the current site w…
New Yorker is the best pizza in Fort Collins. Best sauce to crust ratio, good quality cheese and an all around delicious taste.
S
Sara M
Emerging Expert • 56 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/3/23
• DoorDash order
Caesar salad was a waste of $4. the dressing did not even taste like normal Caesar and there was no cheese on it. So it was lettuce and we were dressing.
The soda was warm.
The pizza was slightly warm and the box was covered in what looks like another pizzas sauce or something.
Cannolis are decent.
L
Lori M
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/23/23
• DoorDash order
The pizza crust was burned, it was really greasy, and there were barely any toppings. Pretty gross actually and not worth the money.
L
Lori M
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/2/25
• DoorDash order
Caesar salad was good - love the pita instead of croutons. The pizza was quite burned on one side - someone should have noticed that before putting it in the box as there were inedible pieces.
A
Amanda W
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/8/25
• DoorDash order
Honestly terrible. Spent $50 on 1 pizza and 4 cheese knots. Everything arrived cold. Additional toppings were left off. Crust was burnt. Not just underneath but visibly around the edges. Not good experience.
