I have had wonderful experiences ordering from here every time. The pizza is always hot and fresh, and most times they upgrade my Pizza (9") (Small 6 SLS) to a Pizza (12") (Medium 8 SLS) for free, which is super super nice! I'm sad that I'm moving further away but will definitely make a special trip for this pizza after i move! I love their plain cheese pizzas.
K
Katherine S
Local Expert • 25 contributions
Loved
• 4/14/26
• DoorDash order
There is NO picture that could ever portray the flavor of these pizzas; my pictures definitely don't do this place justice.
So, I used to work at an authentic Italian/Sicilian restaurant- they had brick oven pizzas and before trying Pizza Pan, I wasn't able to find any pizza in the past 10 years that measured up to the ones from that restaurant... then I tried this Bbq Chicken Pizza.
When I say it is the best pizza I've ever had, that's no small feat. I've had multiple bbq chicken pizzas from an assortment of places and none of them even come close to this!!!
Both pizzas were extremely hot and fresh when they were delivered! We had to blow on them and try to wait to eat them as to not burn our mouths, after the first bite of that bbq one, the heat no longer mattered, we started digging in regardless.
The Pizza (12") (Medium 8 SLS) was a tad undercooked. But the crust was still delicious, it had the perfect amount of cheese, and the sauce was a sweet red sauce. I wish I got a picture showing the gooey cheese string. It had to be cut with a pizza cutter to stop all of the cheese sliding off the top.
This will absolutely be a go-to for us in the future. Don't take my word for it though, try it! If you like fresh, homemade-tasting pizzas with sweeter sauces, I promise you won't be disappointed!
C
Cara K
Local Expert • 71 contributions
Liked
• 1/31/26
• DoorDash review
m a total pizza snob, so trust me when I say this place is quickly becoming my favorite pizza spot in the Valley. I had a special request for my pizza to be baked lightly, and it arrived perfectly cooked—not underdone, not overdone—just right, with incredible flavor in every bite. Topping were so fresh!
I ordered the smallest size and they happened to be out, but instead of canceling my order, they upgraded me to a larger pizza at no extra cost. That kind of customer service goes a long way.
Between the attention to detail, the quality, and the flavor, this place truly understands pizza. If you’re serious about good pizza in Youngstown, this spot deserves your business. 🍕👏
C
Cara K
Local Expert • 71 contributions
Liked
• 1/31/26
• DoorDash review
m a total pizza snob, so trust me when I say this place is quickly becoming my favorite pizza spot in the Valley. I had a special request for my pizza to be baked lightly, and it arrived perfectly cooked—not underdone, not overdone—just right, with incredible flavor in every bite.
I ordered the smallest size and they happened to be out, but instead of canceling my order, they upgraded me to a larger pizza at no extra cost. That kind of customer service goes a long way.
Between the attention to detail, the quality, and the flavor, this place truly understands pizza. If you’re serious about good pizza in Youngstown, this spot deserves your business. 🍕👏
S
S S
6 contributions
Loved
• 9/3/25
• DoorDash order
Haven't lived in the are long and have been trying all the local pizza joints as we have read that the pizza in Youngstown is unmatched. Tried Pizza Pan on a whim and let me say, this place has delicious pizza, period. We got the chicken bacon ranch and the crust, mmm so buttery and crispy. Just perfection. The Stromboli, equally delicious. Try it, it's good.
