Try the best pizzas in Garden City to find a new favorite.
Many pizzerias in Garden City provide more than pizza, so sample some of the city's other delicacies.
Pizza Supreme features a wide variety o…
the best damn meatballs... their unique square pizza, great other pizza styles , great baked dishes....been eating at pizza supreme for over 40 years, way back when they were in the mall ............Erik
M
Michael F
Local Expert • 40 contributions
Loved
• 1/10/24
• DoorDash order
Great pizza! Grew up on their square pies. Unique and delicious!
Slice wasnt packaged well and was ruined-couldve been dasher
C
Cristine G
4 contributions
Loved
• 5/8/24
• DoorDash order
Always perfection. Tradition continues to always have pizza supreme to celebrate my birthday! Thank you
J
Jessica L
5 contributions
Loved
• 7/27/23
• DoorDash order
Yum!! Perfectly cooked and crispy, arrived hot. Probably one of the best rice balls I've had.
T
Taffey B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/10/25
• DoorDash order
The pizza was not completely done. Cheese sliding all over. This is our favorite place but very disappointed this time.
