First order from Plimoth General Store. Packaging was awesome, could tell they really care about what they do there. Attention to small details. They wrote a nice message on the box, the utensils were also carefully packaged. The Mayflower: Turkey Melt Sandwich was excellent, very tasty and carefully constructed. The Cinnamon Roll was clearly homemade and carefully packaged. They went as far as cutting a small piece of wax paper and placing underneath to keep it from sticking to the container. Who else pays attention to details like that in a takeout order?! It was also warmed, great on this cold day. I got Apple Cider to drink which was perfect. 10/10, will be ordering again or going in person.
D
David L
Local Expert • 26 contributions
Loved
• 4/16/25
• DoorDash order
Amazing. Never been let down by them. Their sandwiches are fantastic. They are a little pricey, but it is well worth it. You get what you pay for, there's no way around that. You can tell everything is meticulously made with attention to minor details. The handwritten inspirational quotes on the packaging are such a nice touch. Some may think it's unnecessary, but it always makes me smile, especially during a hectic workday.
C
Conor G
2 contributions
Liked
• 5/29/26
• DoorDash order
it was pretty good, but definitely not worth the expensive pricing. I feel like I wasn't given the value I should've been given. The best part of a Thanksgiving sandwich is stuffing and cranberry sauce, but they had barely really put any in. I also got the s'mores coffee, which was pretty good, but coffee was brewed more on the bitter side. I would definitely try again, but I don't recommend DoorDash anything from this place because it's not worth the additional $20 
M
Michelle M
2 contributions
Loved
• 4/14/26
• DoorDash order
The Harvest: Cranberry Chicken Salad Sandwich was wonderful, the sourdough was perfectly toasted and every bite of the sandwich was delicious and fresh. The coffee was creamy and not too sweet and the fizzes are so refreshing! Definitely will make this a regular spot.
D
Daniel D
3 contributions
Liked
• 6/22/25
• DoorDash order
I got the Italian, and I am a huge Italian sub connoisseur. In my opinion, they've made it far too sweet. Sweet onions, sweet relish. At least I know what not to ask for next time. In my opinion, the sub would be far better without the sweet onions (maybe regular onions) and traditional hots. The brown sugar coffee was delicious.
