Popei's Clam Bar has been one of Long Island's best venues to eat fresh seafood and have a good time since 1991. The Clam Bar's cheerful and energetic atmosphere is enhanced by our friendly and engagi…
The Elvis burger was amazing and such a big portion. The shrimp basket was perfectly crispy. The tiramisu was impressively delicious
L
Lance H
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/1/23
• DoorDash order
Over Stuffed Baked Clams (3) were ok certainly not overstuffed at all but taste great! The main dish which we bought 2 of Sealightful was not good. One of us had two bites and discarded the dish, I ate just the shrimp only out of the dish bc it was not cheap and I needed to eat. Next to no lobster, little to no crab, tasted of vinegar slightly, like a mush of weird sauce and pasta for a lot of $ after fees tip etc.
J
Jo K
Emerging Expert • 54 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/20/25
• DoorDash order
There were two shrimp and four scallops mixed wit the other ingredients . As soon as I opened it I saw it was not like other times. A lot less. Fifty dollars feel like I was robbed.
G
Greg L
Local Expert • 121 contributions
Liked
• 5/5/26
• DoorDash order
Seafood Bisque was good, I think it's mostly imitation crab meat which is meh. The Cavatelli was ok except it was rigatoni. And the sea legs were imitation crab. So everything tasted good and arrived hot but way too much fake seafood for my taste.
J
Johanna A
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/23/26
• DoorDash order
I understand it's not the safest way to order oysters, but you did not put ice on the bottom. All I got was lettuce. That's not how you present someone's ordering oysters on a half shell on lettuces you basically gave me something that looks like I can't even eat it and I spent a lot of money with DoorDash and Popeye on my own
