Popolari. Neapolitan Pizza, Classic American Pizza, and Homemade Pasta are served in this retro/chic Italian pizza and pasta bar. Brookdale is a neighborhood in Montclair that borders Glen Ridge. Ther…
The best penne vodka Ive ever had. I e been looking for a penne vodka that matchs and nothing seems to compare its fresh and creamy and perfect. The garlic knots are fresh and doughy with lots of flavor. Ordering from here again for sure
R
Robert B
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/15/25
• DoorDash order
Chicken Francese was so salty it was inedible
Eggplant Rollattini tasted like they added a glass of wine to it and didn't simmer the alcohol down at all. Has potential but very let down, and pricey for the small portions.
A
Aixa B
2 contributions
Loved
• 12/11/22
• DoorDash order
First time ordering on a rainy, cold Sunday afternoon. Sooooo pleased to enjoy FRESH made pasta. It literally tastes soooo much better than any other pasta on DoorDash.ore elevated, packaged well, incuded green garnish on the pasta. So beautiful when I opened the tray. Garlic knots were warm and fluffy, seemed freshly baked. I had the spicy vodka and it had just the right amount of spice, it was not too much, just a little kicl definitely something that non-spice lovers would enjoy. Had it plain and it was amazing. I am so happy I found this place. Thank you so much!!!!
D
David F
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/26/26
• DoorDash review
The quality of the food doesn't justify the price. The pizza is subpar it was burnt, dough was hard and not soft at all just didn't taste good for how expensive it is.
Also the garlic knots were very hard as soon we got them. I did a takeout order so maybe it's different if you eat there but still quality should be consistent in restaurant and out. The inside is beautiful and staff are friendly wish I could say something positive about the food.
E
Erick L
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/7/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered a 16" Pepperoni Americana and Chicken Fingers and Fries. They forgot to package my pizza and the waitress (as always) had an attitude and lacks effort. The food is good but their wait staff isn't good.
