Portland Pie Co.
4.5(3k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.5(3k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
11:00 am - 8:40 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
16" Large Cheese Pizza
$20.70
•89% (47)
Old Port Pepperoni
$17.43
•92% (50)
#3 Most liked
Moosehead Loaded
$17.43
•100% (26)
14" Crispy Thin Crust Pizza
$17.43
•90% (33)
Nor'Easter Buffalo
$17.43
•81% (11)
The County Twice Baked Potato
$17.43
•100% (29)
Reviews3k+ ratings • 90+ public reviews
4.5
of 5 stars
R
Robin B
3 contributionsLoved
• 9/16/24We couldn wait to tuck into our pie, so, no pic this time. This is my favorite pizza in he area. The crusts are amazingly chewy and delicious. We got the Old P pet Pepperoni this time and it never disappoints. The hand cut pepperoni is huge and spiced just right. But my favo pizza here is the Patuckaway Parm! Pizza can be divis but I can'tima anyone not loving their pizza.
C
Cat M
Local Expert • 53 contributionsDidn't like
• 4/19/25The Eagle Ridge Steak Bomb was an absolute disapointment. Whomever cooked it didn't even bother breaking the sliced steak up. It was dumped on a grill and left until the outside was dark brown and hard, cheese slices placed on it and the whole block of steak and unmelted cheese promptly placed in raw bread. I cannot believe I paid $15 for it. I hadn't ordered for many months as my last order was also carelessly prepared and unable to be eaten. This used to be a great place. All food from the daytime is typically well prepared and good. The night staff however leave much of to be desired.
The Brownie looked okay but was slimy/damp on bottom.
C
Craig B
7 contributionsLoved
• 6/13/25I dont usually leave reviews, good or bad. But this pizza needs recognized! 14" Crispy Thin Crust Pizza with pepperoni. Possibly the BEST pizza I've ever eaten! New York? Detroit? Chicago? Nah, Bangor Maine is the pizza place to go!
R
Rachel J
5 contributionsLiked
• 6/18/25The Harbormaster BBQ was very good I got it with the beer regular crust and it was well seasoned and filling. The Cheesy Breadsticks reminded me of a cheese pizza and honestly everything was way too much food for me but good and I will be eating leftovers which was the plan anyways. The only disappointment I had was the Garden Salad, I ordered the entree size and I swear it was the same size as a side salad so just too pricey.
W
Wendy M
Emerging Expert • 16 contributionsLiked
• 12/8/25Pizza was good, but I paid just under $20 for a 10 inch pie so I really think it should've had more toppings on it. Could use a second sour cream too. Brownie was huge, but badly burned and so hard I could only eat a small part of it. The half Caesar salad had teeny-tiny croutons on it that were all completely soft, so I just picked them off and threw them out. Decent amount of cheese on the salad, the Romain was a little wilted and soft, and the dressing was just typical Caesar dressing. I wish that Portland pie offered a smaller Caesar salad and I also wish that they would have their croutons in some kind of a container on the side so you could add them right before eating so they wouldn't go soft because croutons are one of the best parts of Caesar salad, right?
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Appetizers
Salads
Dressing - apple cider vinaigrette, ranch, balsamic vinaigrette, bleu cheese, parmesan peppercorn, roasted red pepper. Vegan dressing - Italian, lemon vinaigrette. Add chicken or add steak for additional cost.
Sandwiches
Bread options - brioche roll (vegan), basil focaccia (vegan), Italian roll (vegan), sun-dried tomato wrap (vegan) gluten-free for an additional cost. All sandwiches served with potato chips. Choose fruit salad or side salad for additional cost.
Specialty Pies
Sizes - 10", 10" gluten-free basil or cauliflower, 14" thin or 16". Choose your dough flavor beer | basil | garlic.
Build Your Own Pizza
Calzone
Choose your dough flavor beer | basil | garlic gluten free with an additional charge
Pasta
Garlic bread and a half salad - Caesar or Garden