Everything in my order was excellent. The Italian sandwich was fresh, loaded with toppings, and had a great balance of flavors. The bread was toasted perfectly—crispy on the outside without being hard or dry. The broccoli cheddar soup was hot, creamy, and had plenty of broccoli and cheese flavor. The portions were generous, everything was packaged well, and the order arrived exactly as requested. Definitely one of the better sandwich-and-soup meals I’ve had delivered. I’ll absolutely be ordering from Potbelly again.
A
Amanda F
15 contributions
Liked
• 2/7/25
• DoorDash order
The only negative I have, and granted it's high in most places, but it's the price. Granted the delivery tip only, and the bit of tax added to the food raised it, but it still was around 16 bucks per sandwich even with no sides merely for the fact the up-charge for adding things seems excessive imo. 3.49 or whatever it was for adding avocado? over 4 bucks per regular beverages ? I spent less on a beverage at Olive garden just yesterday and get refills. lol. The food is filling for sure, and delicious, but they also seem a bit smaller than subway for the same cost with drinks and chips or cookies. I'd like to see add-on items reduced, as well as the beverages. I'd order from here more often in lieu of spending more once in a blue moon as a treat.
L
Lydia D
Emerging Expert • 23 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/29/23
• DoorDash order
Sandwich was dry, very dry! Needed more mayo, lettuce and tomato. And there was no apparent cheese as stated in the sandwhich's description. I chose Swiss.
To be fair there was loads of chicken and bacon but the secret to a true club sandwich is a balance of ingredients. Another point, classic clubs are made with turkey, not chicken and the meat is sliced not chunked. As I said earlier, it's made up of a balance of ingredients.
This was my first purchase from Pot Belly. I'll reserve judgement for now. ( It was a noble amount of chicken and bacon!)
J
Joel B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/7/26
• DoorDash order
Gave me practically 0 sauce when I ordered garlic aioli and had to pay extra for it.
