Pots & Pans Pie Co. is a woman-owned Indianapolis bakery specializing in sweet and savory pies and pastries. Since 2016 we've made a name for ourselves by respecting the classics while putting a new s…
The Mushroom, Potato, & Bleu Cheese Handpie is sooooooo tasty--buttery, flaky pastry, with the perfect seasoning to complement the mouth-watering, savory filling. Santa approved! And the tangy cranberries lifted the sweetness of the custard, adding just the right holiday punch to the delectable Cranberry Cream Pie Slice. I look forward to ordering this again.
G
Gabriel S
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/6/26
• DoorDash order
Chicken pot pie and broccoli cheddar pies were both very bland and very heavy on potato. The Mac n cheese was also extremely bland. I wouldn't have minded how boring and mediocre everything was if it hadn't cost us $70 for just those 3, 6" items.
L
Lola D
2 contributions
Liked
• 12/30/25
• DoorDash order
So glad my favorite guilty pleasure is on DD. You can't go wrong, it's all delicious. The chai cookie is to die for! The frozen pies are worth every dime.
A
Arthur C
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/6/26
• DoorDash order
Is such an inconvenience that I had to have the pie re-ordered because they failed to follow up and put the right amount in the bag I ordered a whole pie which is $38 and some change and I got two slices what can be done for the inconvenience
A
Alexis H
5 contributions
Loved
• 9/5/25
• DoorDash order
I CANNOT BELIEVE HOW GOOD THIS PB&J PIE AND SHORTBREAD COOKIE ARE!!!! I got this after a depressing week at work and feels like I got a promotion and a four day work week after eating here. Please never stop baking for us Hoosiers. I love you Ms. Pots & Pans Pie Co.
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Sweet Pie (Slices)
We rotate our sweet pies seasonally to provide you with fresh, local ingredients and a fresh menu each month - while our most popular pies stay on the menu year 'round so there's something for everyone to love.
Sweet Pies (9" Whole)
We rotate our sweet pies seasonally to provide you with fresh, local ingredients and a fresh menu each month - while our most popular pies stay on the menu year 'round so there's something for everyone to love.
Take & Bake Pot Pies (FROZEN) 6” and 9"
Our Take & Bake Pot Pies are filled with hearty, scratch-made fillings and wrapped in our signature flaky, all-butter crust. Choose from comforting classics and seasonal favorites - just pop in the oven and enjoy a warm meal without the prep. Perfect for family dinners, cozy nights in, or gifting a little comfort. 6" feeds (1 - 2) , 9" feeds (4-6)
