Thr calzone was Not greasy like how other places usually make it and I loved that and the Toasted Raviolis were really flavorful
B
Braden M
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/16/25
• DoorDash order
I wanted to hope that one local pizza place in this town was appetizing despite prices, but after this, my hopes have been dashed.
The pizza was the most greasy mess I have ever had to taste, I'm sure if I were to let it cool, it would make a thick, solid layer across the entire top of the pizza. Not only that, the crust was crunchy and chewy all at different spots and you could never tell what your next bite would entail. The cheese was just poor quality, not melty or stretchy, but greasy and fragmented. Not to mention, there were burned pieces of what may have been mine or a previous customer's pizza stuck to the bottom of the pie.
I honestly hate writing poor reviews, but $18.50 for a 13" thin crust pepperoni pizza from this place is insane. I would go to any other chain over this place in a heartbeat until they fix their pizza or lower the cost of this to $8.50.
J
Jennifer G
Emerging Expert • 23 contributions
Loved
• 3/11/25
• DoorDash order
Caul crust is amazing! Got it for the first time added pepperoni and sausage. Perfect! The fried mushrooms were delicious and I was wishing they had more in the box. The large pepperoni thin crust was very crispy and delicious. Fast delivery and will definitly order again!
J
Jennifer B
2 contributions
Liked
• 1/3/26
• DoorDash order
My thin crust pizza was so thin. I have never seen one so thin. It was not burnt, but cooked perfectly. The taste of the pizza was excellent.
T
Tasha H
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/30/25
• DoorDash order
I’ve been going to Pryor’s since I was a little girl—over 30 years now—and it’s always been a cherished tradition to stop by whenever I’m in town. That’s why this experience was so incredibly disappointing. I was excited to see they were on DoorDash and couldn’t wait to enjoy a taste of my childhood, but what I received was nothing like the Pryor’s I grew up loving.
The pizza was honestly the worst I’ve ever had from them. The crust was soft, undercooked, and had a strange powdery texture that made it nearly inedible. Even worse, our Deluxe pizza had only four pepperonis total—it felt like a sad mistake, not the quality or care I’ve come to expect from this place.
It’s heartbreaking to see a longtime favorite fall so far short, especially when it once meant so much to me. I hold great memories of enjoying their pizza with my great Aunts and grandma, I truly hope this was just a fluke, but it was a major letdown.
