Puddletown Bagels offers 13 delicious flavors of New York style boiled bagels. Our bagels are free of additives and preservatives, boiled and baked daily. Our menu includes an assortment of signature …
Puddletown is amazing. I've never had a bad experience and we order from them a couple times a months! We get bagel sandwiches and love that the bacon ones come with enough so you get a at least some bacon in each bite!!
N
Nitya B
Local Expert • 145 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/12/25
• DoorDash order
The portion of the Signature Spreads was obscenely small for how expensive it is. Bagels were pretty good but the toppings on the onion bagels were burnt.
D
Danielle B
9 contributions
Loved
• 9/18/21
• DoorDash order
I love this place, I order breakfast bagel sandwiches all the time from here and the grandkids like the bagel dogs. Tasty packaged nicely, fast service, quick delivery. I like to share this place w friends and family. One of my top 3 go toooo's
K
Karrie U
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/14/25
• DoorDash order
Good bagels and smear, the Turkey Bagel Sandwich was as expected but, too much lettuce and not enough meat. However, the quality and taste of the Turkey was perfection.
The Lemon Snickerdoodle Cookie was very dry and is the best of two flavor combos that I absolutely love. If the cookie was softer, it would be amazing. Unfortunately, it just broke apart and was too hard. The flavor can't be beat.
I would definitely give this place another go.
J
Javier J
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/17/25
• DoorDash order
Yesterday I ordered here and my bacon was completely blackened. Today I ordered and my cream cheese is not just sparingly, it appears less than mayonnaise would on a sandwhich. I've been having pregnancy cravings of a nice cream cheese breakfast bagel with extra cheddar cheese and I'm a bit disappointed with the minimal efforts to give cream cheese. On the upside everything else was good and the latte is good!
