First time ordering from Rahway Bagels and the breakfast sandwiches were delicious. The homefries were ok but, the portion was big and could easily be split between two people. To-go packaging was really good too
S
Suzanne L
Local Expert • 63 contributions
Loved
• 6/17/25
• DoorDash order
as always, they deliver you the best.the bagel sandwich as always nice. eggs are perfect, and sausage was cooked. Good and hash brown were cooked perfectly. not soggy
N
Nick P
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/23/24
• DoorDash order
My Taylor Ham, Egg and Cheese was $8.55. Added Double Egg, Salt, Pepper and Ketchup. Got non of the extras and was presented with something that has the height of a kitchen sponge. The bagels I would fight my mother for and you can tell are made with passion. The sandwiches are down bad and highway robbery.
S
Steve Y
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Loved
• 12/23/23
• DoorDash order
The only thing we ever get from this store is the Bakers Dozen (13 Bagels). Always a wonderful experience when I order from them and will listen to the special instructions on the doordash receipt, except when I ordered once too late in the day and they were out of cinnamon raisin (understandable as it's a popular choice!!) but we never have a problem with their bagels otherwise, usually Ziploc them and fridge them for up to two weeks and everyone gets to have bagels around the holidays, even when that means travelling to PA! That's right, these come with us. They're that good. I wish this review had more than 5 stars, I'd give this place and their bagels a solid 10 every time... Especially since even out of the fridge, they're soft enough for my mother who has a full upper denture to enjoy with cream cheese. and if she's happy, I'm even happier.
F
Francesca B
Emerging Expert • 3 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/26/24
• DoorDash order
Food from here is usually good, but today not so much. My sandwich had barely any meat & no avocados tomatoes or cheese..which is ridiculous being that I paid extra for all three. The cook today was just trash.
