The Red Lion Grog House creates the best restaurant experience by combining culinary brilliance with entertainment value. The Red Lion is not a sports bar; it is Indianapolis' only upmarket English-st…
I had theHouse Salad (Large) and Vanilla Bread Pudding. The Vanilla Bread Pudding was dense with lots of flavor. I enjoyed the frostingthat came with it as well. My House Salad (Large) had lots of fresh lettuce, nothing soggy.
Chris said he loved his Sheppard's Pie . Plus, he loved that it arrived hot and ready to eat.
Will order again.
Kelly P
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/1/24
• DoorDash order
For what the items are priced at, I expected a bit more out of it. I ordered the Portobello & Swiss Sandwich it didn't include the peppers that were in the description, there was barely any cheese on it and there was only one mushroom. I felt the description was a bit misleading.
Basically, I paid $15for a grilled mushroom cap on rye bread. This item needs to be reconfigured to reflect it's high price. Add some lettuce, onions, peppers, more mushrooms, something. Maybe mine was a one off and doesn't reflect what they usually are? I'm not sure. I can only comment on the item I received.
The fries are great and the curry Mild Curry sauce is absolutely amazing. I would jar this stuff up! The Cheese sauce left something to be desired. I liked the onion and pepper bits in it, but the cheese base seemed like it was from a genaric canned cheese product. I think if they used a different cheese base, it could be really good.
Overall it wasn't terrible but $50 for two sandwiches and fries is a bit high if this is how they always come.
S
Stephanie S
Local Expert • 141 contributions
Loved
• 5/10/26
• DoorDash order
Fish & Chips are to die for! Nice. hot and fresh!!! Now instead of 2 orders we order 3 or it isn't enough. If you want slaw, order a side. Vanilla Bread Pudding Scotch Egg is delicious and warm. I love the spicy sauce on the side with everything ! I wish they were two per order. Vanilla Bread Pudding is gorgeous!! Portions are cut way back on door dash. Which is just inconsistent and pricey. Even if so, it is absolutely my favorite place to order Fish & Chips . I highly recommend this 👌
S
Stephanie S
Local Expert • 141 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/22/25
• DoorDash order
Thank God the fish n cFish & Chips looks like they're usingredients the original recipe!😀 Im disappointed my s Scotch Egg, however, it's cut funky with half an egg! and my Vanilla Bread Pudding is beautiful but about thirdof the usual portion th serve.
B
Brandi B
21 contributions
Liked
• 8/27/26
• DoorDash order
Sheppard's Pie was fantastic !
The mushrooms - not so much. They were ordinary frozen and then fried - nothing great and certainly not worth the cost. And it was a SMALL batch too.