Rookie's sports grill and bar has everything you'll need to have a fantastic time your friendly neighborhood appleton sports bar, rookie's sports bar and grill. Come on down to rookie's whether you ju…
I got 3 orders of 6 traditional wings: mango habanero, apple bourbon, and Jamaican jerk. APPLE BOURBON is sooo good. This was my second time ordering this flavor, it did not disappoint both times. Therefore, it will definitely be my go to. The other two flavors were also really good too:) I do want to note that I ordered the wings crispy this time, and I wouldn't recommend that option. The meat is chewy and not as enjoyable. The first time I ordered I didn't make any extra custom selections and the wings were perfect! Which is why i'm giving them a 5. There is no other place I have ordered traditional wings from and actually liked them, the sizes of these guys are good too. Place the order, and try the apple bourbon wings on bone, trust me.
Kyle K
2 contributions
Loved
• 9/11/25
• DoorDash order
1/3# Beer Lovers Burger The beer cheese is to die for. Rookie's Classic Philly Cheesesteak super fresh. Boneless 6 Piece Wings cooked and sauced perfectly. Mozzarella Sticks hot fresh and stringy Will definitely be ordering multiple times.
K
Kyle K
35 contributions
Loved
• 2/21/26
• DoorDash order
Usually places have to earn my trust for me to order their fish, but Mom said she heard good things about Rookies, so I tried it Officially found my new go to for Fish Fry routines, crispy breading and the perch was primo quality! And super orderly container for a sports bar(DEATH TO STYROFOAM)
Pretty sure they make an in house tartar, which makes it that much more of a stand out
M
Mary S
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
Loved
• 5/26/24
• DoorDash order
The food was amazing. the Frisco Melt was cooked to perfection and so yummy. The Ribeye Sandwich has a generous serving of meat and is very filling. The Mac and Cheese Bites were as advertised and delicious. I would order the Frisco Melt with a side of potato salad every time.
K
Karen P
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Loved
• 4/18/26
• DoorDash review
I was expecting large "slabs" of lake perch. What I got was a generous supply of BUTTERFLY PERCH! I didn't think anyone could get that anymore. They were very well prepared, too!
Wonderful!
