Garlic knots were amazing! So soft and fresh. Housemade ranch was also delicious, so yourself a favor and just order the large size! Slice of cheese was massive, probably the equivalent of 3 slices.
K
Kenneth V
8 contributions
Loved
• 12/14/23
• DoorDash order
The Cheese pizza was great. This is the best new York style pizza in Napa. The crust was cooked perfectly with a nice crunch. The sauce was delicious. Glad they're on door dash now and will definitely be ordering again
K
Kathleen B
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/29/26
• DoorDash order
This used to be our favorite pizza, but something has changed with the crust. It doesn't have the same texture & flavor it used to have. Our last 3 orders have been disappointing. Did the recipe change? Bring back the original recipe please. Meantime, we will have to find a different option :(
R
RC R
9 contributions
Loved
• 3/7/26
• DoorDash order
Small Veggie 12"Small Cheese 12" ordered and wasewdy real quick, th flavors are great,crust is perfect, tasty, perfect for pizza night
J
James O
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/11/25
• DoorDash order
We usually love rutherford pizza, but I don't know if they were having an off night or what. We got the chicken Alfredo, it came with no sauce on it and was literally just chicken and cheese on a flavorless crust. We also got a pepperoni pizza with mushrooms, it was better, actually had sauce, but again was bland. I don't like writing bad reviews, but my hope is that Rutherford pizza will see this and look into why the pizza was so bad tonight. This is normally one of our favorite pizza places, now not so sure we will be back, bummer.
