Everything is always so yummy! The Quiche ws HUGE!The yogurt Yogurt Parfait always has fresh fruit. My son loves the Croissant. they're also very very large. We love Sarah's. It's one of our go toos for breakfast and lunch!
L
LaTosha D
Local Expert • 43 contributions
Loved
• 8/20/25
• DoorDash order
The Breakfast Burrito is my favorite item on the menu. All of the flavors go well together, and the sauce is delicious, very light and creamy and fresh! The Breakfast Burrito is more than enough for breakfast, but they have a killer Morning Bun. I'm addicted.
M
Mimi P
1 contributions
Loved
• 3/2/23
• DoorDash review
EVERYTHING Sarah's serves is amazing! From the always fresh and unique salads to the incredible pizza that I can never finish because the serving size is more than enough. The caesar salad with chicken, which they always have, is a great go to. But her bowls are incredibly delicious and always different week after week. Not to mention the Thursday Take Home Dinners are not only super convenient but drool worthy!
Sarah and her stag are the absolute BEST!
S
Sophie T
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/8/23
• DoorDash order
I ordered the supreme pizza, and it was quite excellent. However, for $10, I only got 2 slices when I was under the impression I was getting a small pizza. The pizza came with a side salad, which tasted off. The lettuce tasted expired. I also ordered the kale Caesar salad and the dressing was too acidic for my taste and was practically all lemon. The chicken in the salad also tasted a little old. I did not like that I could not type any requests for my order, as some people prefer their dressing on the side or perhaps less ice for their drinks. Overall, Sarahs will always be a stable restaurant in Wheeling, but for them to succeed as a takeout business, there must be some modifications made.
K
Kaitlyn C
6 contributions
Loved
• 4/13/23
• DoorDash order
Sarah's on Main takes so much care and pride in their business. All their house-made goodies come fast and fresh! The Quiche Florentine is always AMAZING- I've ordered it in store before but never Dashed it- I was impressed, it was still hot when it arrived! I ordered a loaf of the Salty Bread too, it's always great whether you eat it by itself with butter or make it into a sandwich. Love that you can order granola on the side of your parfait, too- I plan to take it to work for breakfast tomorrow so it's nice it won't get soggy.
