What is the Setauket Pastaria's address?

Setauket Pastaria is located at 4082 Nesconset Hwy, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733, USA. This is where you will go to get DoorDash Pickup orders, and where Dashers will go to get your DoorDash delivery orders.

Does Setauket Pastaria offer delivery or pickup?

You can browse Setauket Pastaria’s menu and place an order for both Delivery and Pickup on DoorDash. Setauket Pastaria may also offer delivery and pickup on their own or through other delivery services.

What are the most popular dishes at Setauket Pastaria?

The dishes most commonly ordered by DoorDash customers at Setauket Pastaria are 16" Large Pizza, Create Your Own 12" Personal Pie and Pasta with Vodka Sauce.

Is Setauket Pastaria a DashPass eligible store?

Setauket Pastaria offers DashPass benefits like $0 delivery, reduced service fees, and $5 credits back on Pickup orders. If you want to know if a store is DashPass eligible, you can look for the DashPass icon next to their name.

DoorDash

Home

Setauket- East Setauket

Italian

Setauket Pastaria

4.5Icon Loading(500+)•
Icon LoadingDashPass•
Pizzeria•

Store Info

DashPass

4.5(500+)•

$$•Pizzeria

Full Menu

10:00 am - 9:10 pm

Featured Items

$0 delivery fee, first order

pricing & fees

to see delivery time

Featured Items

Pasta with Vodka Sauce

2 for $19.95$39.90

Buy 1, get 1 free

Italian Salad

2 for $14.95$29.90

Buy 1, get 1 free

16" Large Pizza

$23.00

•85% (57)

#1 Most liked

Regular Pizza Slice

2 for $4.25$8.50

Buy 1, get 1 free

Create Your Own 12" Personal Pie

$14.00

•90% (32)

#2 Most liked

Eggplant Rollatini

2 for $15.95$31.90

Buy 1, get 1 free

Reviews500+ ratings • 30+ public reviews

4.5
Icon Loading
of 5 stars

G
Genevieve R
15 contributions
Icon LoadingLoved
• 12/14/23
• DoorDash order

ALWAYS EXCELLENT EVERYTHING!

BETTER THAN O SOLO MIO........ANYTIME.....NO COMPARISON!

L
Linda Anne L
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Icon LoadingLiked
• 3/26/26
• DoorDash order

We took advantage of the Buy One Get One with the Eggplant Rollatini. Huge portion, perfectly packaged along with delicious sesame seed rolls and butter. Will definitely order again.

M
Melissa C
3 contributions
Icon LoadingDidn't like
• 4/19/26
• DoorDash order

The sauce on the pasta does not taste good at all. My 7 year old ate the 5 Pieces Chicken Fingers so I guess they were ok. The meatballs were just ok. For an Italian  place on long island it's pretty shameful lol it tstates like what you would get if you got Italian in like Ohio or something.

M
Maria G
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Icon LoadingLoved
• 8/7/25
• DoorDash order

So much toppings Amazing tastes

K
Kristin K
3 contributions
Icon LoadingDidn't like
• 7/27/24
• DoorDash order

Disappointed. First time customer via Door Dash. Order was incorrect. The order ticket appeared to have been transferred incorrectly from Door Dash to the kitchen. My name was correct on the kitchen ticket as were two of the three items. My child received a two piece meatball side (ticket said 3 piece meatball side) when I ordered a Pasta with 2 Piece Meatballs .  Needless to say there was a young child looking for pasta and crying at dinner tonight.  Door Dash offered an easy refund for the error.

Red tomato based sauces are hit or miss for me. The Gnocchi itself was well done and the fresh mozzarella melted on top of it was really good. I didn't personally care for the taste of the sauce.  Others may really like it. 

The 12” Margarita Pie wasn't what I expected.  Mine arrived with cheese that didn't appear to be the usual fresh mozzarella like was on the gnocchi dinner. It was much more yellow and solid across the pie and had a considerable amount of oregano sprinkled all over the cheese. 

With so many other great options around I likely won't return.

See All

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Appetizers

Salads

Add grilled chicken for an additional charge. Served with Italian bread and butter.

Soups

Served with Italian bread and butter.

Pastaria Delights

Heroes

Side Orders

Pizza

Specialty Pies

Veal

Served with your choice of pasta, salad or potatoes and vegetables and with Italian bread and butter.

Chicken

Served with your choice of pasta, salad or potatoes and vegetables and with Italian bread and butter.

Shrimp

Served with your choice of pasta, salad or potatoes and vegetables and with Italian bread and butter.

Vegetable

Served with your choice of pasta, salad or potatoes and vegetables and with Italian bread and butter.

Pasta Specials

Substitute sauce for an additional charge.

Pastaria Pasta

Served with Italian bread and butter. Substitute sauce for an additional charge.

Beverages (Archived)

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

Store Info