Sheffield Public House is a locally owned and operated international pub with fresh ingredients and fresh vibes! Our mediterranean recipes come directly from our owner David and his mother who we call…
We had the Kafteres, Greek Chopped Salad, Souvlaki with pork loin, and Fish and Chips. None were disappointing. The Kafteres offered an exciting mixture of goat cheese and banana peppers. I love both individually, but could never have imagined the mouth-watering combination. Amazingly, the Fish and Chips arrived crispy and flavorful - even the tartar sauce had a notably pleasant flavor. The Greek Chopped Salad was fresh and offered no suggestion that it had traveled for 20 minutes. After trying everything else, we had little room for the pork loin Souvlaki, but did that the time for a few bites. How gorgeously flavorful! Again, there was no withering by car. The pork was savory and the wrap was warm and fresh. The only drawback is app related wherein requesting a side salad with extra cheese adds the cheese to the entree. That's programming - not a culinary drawback. I'm amazed and can't wait to try more dishes.
C
Crystal D
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/18/26
• DoorDash order
Mac and cheese had zero flavor and no panko crumbs. $5 glazed carrots barely covered the bottom of the cup- literally a laughable amount. Greek salad was all bitter lettuce, unripe vegetables, and one crumb of feta. Mediterranean Platter was generous-sized but also completely flavorless. So disappointing!
J
Jackie L
9 contributions
Loved
• 11/12/25
• DoorDash order
That mac and cheese was not born in your school cafeteria. It's a new breed. Its cheeses blend flavors smoothly, no rubberiness. The pasta is as al dente as al dente gets. The red pepper salsa adds delicate heat whenever you want it. This dish will change your idea of what mac and cheese can be. The Sheffield Public House Entree Baked Mac and Cheese is perfection.
C
Caleb W
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
Liked
• 12/19/25
• DoorDash order
Great pub burger! Bacon, cheese, pickle and onion with a couple dabs of catsup....yesssir. The fries are great, not soggy, and the herbs with the flaky salt was the perfect finish.
J
Jessica H
3 contributions
Loved
• 8/22/25
• DoorDash order
I had the Baked Spaghetti. It was so delicious. Noodles cooked perfectly. Perfect amount of meat/sauce/cheese. I believe I have found my new comfort meal in town.
