What is the Sibley Mart's address?

Sibley Mart is located at 2465 E High Ave, New Philadelphia, OH 44663, USA. This is where you will go to get DoorDash Pickup orders, and where Dashers will go to get your DoorDash delivery orders.

Does Sibley Mart offer delivery or pickup?

You can browse Sibley Mart’s menu and place an order for both Delivery and Pickup on DoorDash. Sibley Mart may also offer delivery and pickup on their own or through other delivery services.

What are the most popular dishes at Sibley Mart?

The dishes most commonly ordered by DoorDash customers at Sibley Mart are 8 Piece Mixed, Small Tender Box and 12” Pizza.

Is Sibley Mart a DashPass eligible store?

Sibley Mart offers DashPass benefits like $0 delivery, reduced service fees, and $5 credits back on Pickup orders. If you want to know if a store is DashPass eligible, you can look for the DashPass icon next to their name.

Sibley Mart

4.3Icon Loading(100+)•
Icon LoadingDashPass•
Convenience•

Store Info

DashPass

4.3(100+)•

$$•Convenience

Sibley Mart is a well-lit, family-friendly facility. It's the convenience shop in your hometown. For travelers and busy moms, we strive for quick service. We are proud of our courteous service, cleanl…

All Day

8:00 am - 6:35 pm

Featured Items

$0 delivery fee, first order

pricing & fees

to see delivery time

Featured Items

8 Piece Mixed

$15.49

•90% (10)

#1 Most liked

12” Pizza

$15.00

Small Tender Box

$8.49

Italian Salad

$6.49

Fresh Garden Salad

$5.99

Chicken Nibbler Cup

$5.49

Reviews100+ ratings • 10+ public reviews

4.3
Icon Loading
of 5 stars

J
Jonalee F
5 contributions
Icon LoadingLoved
• 10/17/26
• DoorDash order

Hunt Bros is the best, most underrated pizza around! I'm not normally a pepperoni and cheese girlie, but this reminds me of pizza from my high school days and is my absolute favorite!

M
Matthew B
19 contributions
Icon LoadingDidn't like
• 10/24/26
• DoorDash order

33 Piece Dark Snack+Small Tender Box wereboth extremely salty. so much  so that they weren't edible. Fresh Garden Salad was anythingredients but fresh with brown leave and slimy

G
Greg H
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
Icon LoadingLiked
• 1/3/26
• DoorDash order

Great chicken and the only place around with spicy fried chicken. This is the only restaurant I'm buying fried chicken from, from now on. Amazing flavor. 

M
Makayla P
4 contributions
Icon LoadingLiked
• 2/23/26
• DoorDash order

Honestly the breakfast pizza was so good maybe get extra sauce next time. The chicken was delicious and fresh and the jojos are the best around

L
Larry R
15 contributions
Icon LoadingDidn't like
• 12/17/25
• DoorDash review

I've ordered chicken and JoJo's twice, the Chicken was great both times.i have never gotten the JoJo's, I've ordered them both times, just never received them. 5 stars for the Chicken, minus 2 stars for not giving me any JoJo's.

See All

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Subs & Sandwiches

Pizza

Original or Thin crust. Hunk= ¼ of a 12” Pizza.

Burgers

all burgers are ¼ lb Angus.

Salads

All Salads include lettuce, cherry tomatoes, green peppers, onions, banana peppers, black olives, hard-boiled egg, and shredded cheddar cheese.

Chicken & Jo’s

Only served Monday-Saturday 10a.m. to 9p.m. and Sunday's 10a.m.-5p.m.

Uncle Ray's Potato Chips

Beverages

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

Prices may differ between Delivery and Pickup.