"Our Rutherford restaurant, located in the center of Midtown, delivers The New American Cuisine in a relaxed bistro environment. Our carefully created menu, superb service, and welcoming atmosphere en…
Absolutely delicious! Salad was great and short ribs the best! Heard the rumor that the salad was identical to the old Rutherford House. It did not disappoint.
D
Dana M
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/18/24
• DoorDash order
Honestly, from what I heard about this place I was excited to try it, but I was seriously disappointed. First off, the Grilled Chicken Sandwich was not even made how it was supposed to be. It was supposed to have tomato and arugula on it, I asked for no tomato, which there werent. However, they put literally 2 leaves of arugula on it (not an under exaggeration) and added roasted red peppers.....?? Guess they made whatever they felt like instead of what I ordered.
The Lemon & Ricotta Pancakes were delicious but for $18 the 3 pancakes were extremely small, like maybe the size of my palm. Not at all worth the price.
Additionally, when you pay $9 for a side of Sweet Potato Fries, you typically expect to get more than a handful of them. Maybe that's just me, but $9 felt like a total rip off for the amount.
And the Classic Eggs Benedict had almost no hollandaise sauce on them. We were not impressed. Ive had better benedicts at the diner (that were less expensive too).
All in all, disappointing all around, and I wont be back.
K
Kyle T
14 contributions
Loved
• 3/16/26
• DoorDash order
I don't know how this restaurant doesn't have five stars across the board. It tastes great every time. You can tell the food is fresh and the dishes are unique. This is the second time having the Sonoma burger and it's just as good as the first highly recommend.
K
Kyle T
14 contributions
Loved
• 3/3/26
• DoorDash order
The Sonoma Burger was absolutely outstanding. The flavor was robust and it was cooked perfectly. Excellent combination of toppings. Loved the garlic aoli. Highly recommend.
M
Milagros H
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/8/24
• DoorDash order
the Chorizo Guacamole Eggs Benedict was not great. the avocado had a sour taste and browning. it was not fresh at all. lack of salt and seasoning as well. would not order again
