Wow! First of all, customer service was outstanding. Second, the food was yummy! The bagels are a good size but not too thick for this concept to work. My Reedy Reuben was packed with lean, flavorful corned beef. My only change for future orders would be to request light on the spicy mustard. Also, the kraut is good, you know it's there, but it doesn't overpower the sandwich. My husband got the Club Steamer and loved his as well. As for the Cookie* and the Big Pickle*, they are both ginormous! Really enjoyed this experience and will be ordering again soon!
M
Mel J
Local Expert • 70 contributions
Loved
• 3/17/25
• DoorDash order
Oh wow. Wow, wow, WOW! I finally tried Sully's for the first time this past weekend, and plan on getting lunch there again today! I got Vulcan and added some turkey and italian dressing to it; while having a warm veggie sandwich was a little weird, it was still absolutely amazing! The hummus was very tasty. They're one of the last places left that serve sprouts, which I love! My SO got The Hulk because he wanted something with "lots of meat", and he was not disappointed! Could not stuff these in our faces fast enough! Big Pickle* also was exactly what I was hoping for in a "barrel deli pickle". I can't wait to work myself through all their offerings. Humongous sandwiches with super tasty ingredients.
J
Jordan F
20 contributions
Loved
• 10/31/24
• DoorDash order
The bagels are always impeccable. In particular the Breakfast Bagel; filled to the brim with goodness. In the mood for something classic? The Bagel w/ Spread is *chefs kiss*. If are in the market for a great breakfast, then get here and get a bagel down ya neck!
L
Linda N
4 contributions
Loved
• 8/13/25
• DoorDash review
I ordered the bacon, egg and cheese. Added extra bacon, cheese and a slice of tomato. This was the largest and most delicious breakfast bagel I have ever had. Hands down the best!
L
Lei B
6 contributions
Loved
• 5/6/25
• DoorDash order
IM NOT A BREAKFAST PERSON AND RHIS BAGEL HERE DONE MADE ME INTO ONE !
This was literally the best Breakfast Bagel I ever had .
I will continue to order MANY MANY TIMES ! Maybe daily lol ! Thank you guys . The bagel tasted super fresh , it was super warm also . One of a kind !!
