Surreal Creamery
4.7(2k+)•
DashPass•
Ice Cream & Gelato•
Store Info
DashPass
4.7(2k+)•
$$•Ice Cream & Gelato
https://a816-health.nyc.gov/ABCEatsRestaurants/#!/Search
NEW! Breaking Batter Ice Cream and Cake Jars now available! Mix & Match to create your favorite combination.
Full Menu
3:00 pm - 10:40 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Dulce de Leches Ice Cream Cake Jar
$14.49
•92% (13)
Monster Celebration Ice Cream Cake Jar
$11.99
Make Your Own Flotea
$13.99
•89% (47)
#2 Most liked
Chocolate Meltdown Overload Ice Cream Cake
$11.99
•94% (38)
#3 Most liked
Strawberry Black Tea
$8.49
•90% (32)
Brown Sugar Bubble Tea & Earl Grey Ice Cream
$13.99
•90% (31)
Reviews2k+ ratings • 40+ public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
Melissa G
194 contributionsLoved
• 2/4/25i cannot get enough of Surrealness!! neither can my husband. Talk about total high quality iced cream, choices & mixes & flavors you probably never had. can you say adicting?
So lets start with Monster Celebration Cake and Ice Cream Jar. its a toss up for being my favorite. i prefer the iced cream one. I love the monster flavor & what is added here takes it to next level. i could live on this. Next is I Dream of Taro Cake and Ice Cream Jar. i also prefer iced cream to cream cheese ( the other jar with waffle cookies is way yummmy too!) i never had taro cake or iced cream. id you havent its a must try. i also got Chocolate Meltdown Overload Cake and Ice Cream Jar MOSTLY because there are Coco Puffs in it. so obviously there is a genius at work in this store. The chocolate wasnt too much like chocolate ice cream can be. i got the big jar for this one.
For true originality, make your own jar, or just for the best darn iced cream you will ever have..PLACE AN ORDER HERE!!! Happy Yummys!
Melissa G
194 contributionsLoved
• 1/26/25I spent a very long time on the review of the best iced cream place this iced cream snob has ever been too. im too tired to redo. i will say you will NOT be disappointed i can promise there is something for everyone.
im going to try give you an idea. first all flavors were so fresh and flavorful and creamy. like a slice of heaven. and the mix ins same. Monster Celebration Cake Jar not your usual blue iced cream. no wonder this is in the top 3 best sellers. a must try. picture 1.Chocolate Blackout the best kind of chocolate mix and base since i cant remember when. again so fresh and totally flavorful. i mean..i want more now!! but small freezer lol!I Dream of Taro Cake and Ice Cream Jar if you like Taro..your senses will explode with this combo of flavors. no joke!I Dream of Taro Cake Jar again if you love Taro. look carefully at pics and of course see description. the 2 taro items had different ingrediants but it will blow your senses. CANT WAIT TO REORDER!!
V
Vanessa C
3 contributionsLoved
• 5/16/22They have good selection and combinations of ice cream and bubble tea. Huge serving sizes and if you get the ice cream you get to keep their mason jar. Which makes great storage if you can't finish it in one go. Highly recommend
A
Agnes A
8 contributionsLoved
• 6/12/22I bought 2 mason jars. Cookie And bday. $40 w delivery. Salty, yes. But soooo worth it. It arrived and wasn't melted, and flavor omg. Delivery worth the price!
V
Vivian G
3 contributionsDidn't like
• 6/14/25Dulce Tres Leches jar didn't have any dulce de leche. Jar was filled with more than half with cake. I paid for a glass jar and cake -_-
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store