The Classic Bialy was so pillowy soft and fresh with the perfect amount of onion in the center. If you like dill then the The Bubble sandwich will be your jam. It was so fresh and tasty. The Aww Zhuga Zhuga is such an interesting mix of layered flavors. Both bagel sandwiches were a little on the small side for the price but definitely worth it based on taste and uniqueness.
K
Khadijah L
1 contributions
Loved
• 4/4/25
• DoorDash review
The Israeli coffee 10/10. Idk what they line the cup with but its damn delicious, lemon and dill schmear tastes bright and refreshing paired with an everything bagel. Im excited to order their other schmear flavors! I would have snapped a pic of the bagel....but it was gone in 3 minutes before I remembered to take a pic of it. lol
D
Daniel M
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
Loved
• 11/4/23
• DoorDash order
This is from a born and bred New Yorker who transplanted from Brooklyn, this is the best bagel on the island. I had an everything bagel with lox, capers , cream cheese and lox, it hit the spot. Absolutely the best bagel here and absolutely the closest to a NYC bagel. I loved it. All the other "bagels" you see here are really not good, these guys have it down hands down.
G
Grace C
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/20/25
• DoorDash order
It's extra to order "Brooklyn style" smear, but if you ever order a bagel from Brooklyn then you will be highly disappointed. The consistency of salmon to cream cheese was 99% cream cheese and 1% smoked salmon. It's better to just go with the 6 dollar bagel with lemon dill smear.
C
Cara R
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/14/26
• DoorDash order
we usually LOVE tali's but the order we received today wasn't great. we didn't receive the correct bagels (i.e. got 3 everything instead of our order of 2 sesame and 1 everything). and look, i like cream cheese as much as the next person, but my bagel was drowning in schmear (i literally removed less than half of it and it was enough to thoroughly cover a second bagel). idk. i still love tali's, but the quality control today was not it.
