I've ordered here before and it was excellent. I was extremely disappointed that they would allow a $30 dish to go out burnt. I ordered the Gamberetti and the shrimp and tomatoes were black and overcooked. The shrimp was hard as a rock. It was inedible.
J
Judah B
11 contributions
Liked
• 4/15/26
• DoorDash order
Food great overall. Plain Pasta was good. Mozzarella Bites were ok. Galvania Lemon Soda didn't come. The portions were sized well and the food seemed fresh. I would probably order again.
K
Kimberlee H
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/18/23
• DoorDash order
We ordered two pizza's, they were both over cooked and uncut. Two orderes of cannoli's and they were both melted from being on top of the hot food. Pasta was tasteless. The entire meal was not edible. Very disappointing and a waste of money!
M
Mariella C
Local Expert • 230 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/18/25
• DoorDash order
I'm a fan of Theresa's, but the Plain Cheese Little Round Pizza was overcooked and was not cut. Had to cut it myself and it was almost impossible to cut through or even chew it was so overcooked. I usually dine in, and the food is excellent. I was surprised at how bad this was today, especially not cutting the pizza. I still give 3 stars for all the 5 star food I've eaten inside the restaurant. Not sure what happened today.
