If you like large, soft fluffy bagels with just the right amount of crisp inthe crust, this is the place! They have some funky flavors you may be into but dont miss out on the classic. This is how bagels should be. The spreads are good too. Oh, and of course the pork roll sandwich!
A
Ashley B
13 contributions
Loved
• 4/24/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered an egg bagel with Swiss cheese pork roll spinach spk and it was amazing!the fruit bowl is always great and I couldn't order without getting the crumb cake .The plain bagels were great as well nice and buttered!The hot bagel sandwich was huge I could only eat half lol
K
Kristin R
6 contributions
Loved
• 12/28/25
• DoorDash review
They actually put bacon on their BLT. Real BACON. And it was spectacular. And they know how to make coleslaw! Middletown is my go to breakfast and quick lunch spot. It's always clean, the staff is always friendly and I always take home a 1/2lb of their chicken salad to the fam.
J
Joseph F
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/30/25
• DoorDash order
I will start off with saying sandwich tasted great, but it lacked quite a bit regarding the steak and avocado that was in the sandwich. For a $17 bagel with egg and steak it was extremely skimpy. I would say it had half of whatever the photo on their menu showed. I have ordered here numerous times and it seems that the quality of the sandwiches has gotten worse unfortunately
K
Kimberly C
Emerging Expert • 82 contributions
Loved
• 10/31/25
• DoorDash order
Bagel & Cream Cheese with the vegan vegetablecream cheesewas amazing. it's rare to find delicious vegan options!!! The Create Your Own (hot sandwhich) was also really great. I love being able to customize!
