Only complaint is the giddy up was light on meat. But still awesome. This is our new fav work day food place!!
J
Jude S
2 contributions
Loved
• 4/18/26
• DoorDash order
I, like many others, have become really disenchanted with eating out because the cost to value ratio is so far off balance. I never heard of this place before but tried them only because they were near where I was I'm glad I did. FINALLY a place that gives value for the cost. I got the Bacon Me Crazy Melt - Combo - the bread was done perfectly, the chicken wasn't dried out like everyone else does, the bacon was a good amount and done on the softer side which is exactly how I like it. Plus the dressing - they actually put dressing on not like the tiny dollop everyone else gives you. It could use a tinnnny touch more flavor maybe the ranch dressing if changed might be enough but even still it's excellent as-is. The onion rings were some of the best I've had in ages too. Most are dried and overcooked. These werw done just right and had a great taste. And soooo fast. They had my order ready super quick. I will definitely consider them again. I'm not down this way often but I'd detour to have them again.
S
Susan M
5 contributions
Liked
• 3/30/26
• DoorDash order
Good flavors, a bit smaller than I expected. For a place called the melt I expected more melted cheese too. Well packaged, arrived in good condition. Hot Mess Melt wasn't a mess and the Giddy Up Melt had some nice sized burnt ends. Hubby loved the sauce.
P
Paul S
Local Expert • 30 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/23/24
• DoorDash order
Are you kidding me $19.00 + for this sorry looking sandwich?? Five tiny and extremely salty pieces of meat and 5 small undercooked Onion Rings!! I realized the error in my ways when I searched further for the name of the restaurant Melt Down, which much to my chagrin I found out is the ghost kitchen for Denny's in Centereach, which every time we drive by there not only is the kitchen ghost kitchen, but the place is ghosted because there's nobody there because the food is horrible if I would've known that it was associated with Denny's I never would've ordered it. I almost feel like I was misled, or lied to by DoorDash shame on the both of you and trust me I will not be making this mistake again I will let all my friends and family members know too!!
M
Michael M
9 contributions
Liked
• 8/25/25
• DoorDash order
I agree with other recent reviews that all three sandwiches were on point tasty the review was just bittersweet because as good as they all were perfectly cooked perfectly toasted they just lacked substance. It was almost more bread than what was in between them and I am very upset because they deserve a five star review if they were not so stingy on the filling
