Their pizza has spoiled me for any other pizza! No one else's measure up to theirs!
L
Lynn H
Emerging Expert • 63 contributions
Loved
• 3/15/26
• DoorDash order
Everything was beyond delicious! The Stromboli is my absolute favorite and the meatballs are amazing. The Italian Beef was so tender and flavorful! Huge portions and every bite was a pure delight!
A
Adryan B
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
Liked
• 4/18/26
• DoorDash order
Got half cheese and half pepperoni and sausage on the Medium 12" Pizza. I like the sauce, savory which is how I like my pizzas. I like that they do crumpled sausage instead of the pieces of sausage. The sausage had good flavor to me. A little greasy but expect that from cheese. Nice a starchy not over or undercooked. Ingredients tasted fresh. Salad was good and I liked the dressing, tasted homemade. I'd get it again.
L
Lynn H
Emerging Expert • 63 contributions
Loved
• 12/12/25
• DoorDash order
It has been years since I had a real Stromboli this good!!! I am so happy to find that I can enjoy the taste again! I have really missed The Old Mill food!!! Nothing compares! Everything tastes like the original restaurant recipes!!!!!
J
Jill B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/12/26
• DoorDash order
Pizza. No taste. Crust felt undercooked. Wouldn't order again.
