The Penny Pub

The Penny Pub

4.5
(2,900+ ratings)|
|
Sandwiches, Burgers, Dinner|$$
"About Us The Penny Pub has been a Bay Shore institution since the early 1900s. Our modest tavern, once known as "The Veterans Bar," has been a home for veterans, residents, tourists, family, and frie…
Ratings & Reviews
4.5
2,900+ ratings
5
4
3
2
1

$0.00
delivery fee, first order
to see delivery time
The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders
Mon
12 PM - 2:25 AM
Tues (Today)
12 PM - 2:25 AM
Wed
12 PM - 2:25 AM
Thurs
12 PM - 2:55 AM
Fri
12 PM - 2:55 AM
Sat
12 PM - 2:55 AM
Sun
12 PM - 2:25 AM

Popular Items

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Appetizers

Salads

Entrees

Dipping Sauce (Side) (Copy)

Desserts

Na Beverages (Copy)

Entrees

Desserts

Specials

Dipping Sauce (Side)

Catering

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

Ratings & Reviews
4.5
2,900+ ratings, 21 public reviews
Jericho I
• 10/24/22
DoorDash Order
Best pub food I've tried in Long Island my favorite things were the Penny Burger with a fried eggs on top and those jalapeño poppers are amazing. 10/10 will definitely be trying from again. God Bless the Irish <3
anthony c
• 8/12/22
DoorDash Review
Quesadilla was amazingly and surprisingly delicious! Deff recommend
Zach R
• 3/24/23
DoorDash Review
Chipotle chicken was fire
Maxime E
• 9/29/22
DoorDash Order
Wings was Fire were good , i would recommend ordering them
Rita D
• 12/31/21
DoorDash Order
Delicious hot wings!! The churros with chocolate sauce are amazinggg :) Thanks so much!
Helpful (1)
Anthony F
• 10/6/22
DoorDash Review
Quesedilla are fireeeee