Come in for diner-style meals at restaurant prices. We are conveniently located in Randolph, NJ, at the crossroads of Route 10 and Center Grove Road. Traditional principles are being restored by our m…
I've ordered from here a few times before so I can give a proper review. From the 3 times I've ordered they only messed up 1 time. I ordered a French dip and they forgot the au jus so kinda annoyed cuz it's the whole point of a French dip without the dip it's just French. Jokes aside I was hungry and ate it without the au jus and it was actually really good by itself. French dip can be a bit bland but this was great! The portions are huge!!! The first time I ordered for 2 and got a prime rib with mashed potatoes, Mac & cheese. Along with an assorted appetizer plate and disco fries and a slice of cake. It took us 2 days to eat everything. The menu is bordering infinite really if you got a hankering for something odds are they will have it. Everything is good and fresh tasting. The 3 times I've ordered between 4 people all together everyone enjoyed what they ordered. Really do yourself a favor and check this place out. It's really great for a group of people if everyone is having trouble picking a place. This is my new go too place and besides 1 minor error I really have nothing to complain about and I'm trying lol. I do highly recommend the death by chocolate fudge cake. I wish it had a bit more cake than icing but if you have a sweet tooth you owe it to yourself to get a slice. Anyway hope this helped and if I wasn't clear enough I highly recommend this dinner.
A
Angelina S
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
Loved
• 9/22/24
• DoorDash order
Their food is incredible. They have the best Feta in the world. their tomato are perfect. I have no idea where they get them but they have a perfect flavor and texture. Their pancakes are decent. They are seeetened which makes ideal for Oreo or chocolate chip add ins.
J
Joseph C
10 contributions
Loved
• 4/4/26
• DoorDash order
Well done Randolph Diner, I praise you for fair pricing and the abundance of food as well as quality. Particularly, the grilled chicken sandwich which was made using two whole chicken breasts, try getting this from other eateries without absorbing extra fees or an overpriced sandwich lacking meat. I am very happy with the menu pricing and amount of food and taste, in 2026 I feel this should be highlighted, thank you to the team!
E
Eileen L
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/25/23
• DoorDash order
the Penne Gorgonzola needed something. it was just a scoop of pasta swimming in a tin of sauce. Dont get me wrong, it was delicious, but it came with nothing, and the dish itself could have used some color, like peas or mushrooms or chicken... andnit was definitely not worth $20, as I said, no salad, no soup, no bread.
Ralph M
8 contributions
Liked
• 4/6/25
• DoorDash order
Everything was great as usual. French Fries not so much, over cooked to me and didn't care the coating. Apple Turnovers were huge and delicious. Can't wait to try the Eclairs. unfortunately out of stock and missing the LG Unsweetened Iced Tea which I enjoy was missing .
