Matt and the crew at Toasted Goat absolutely make the best sandwiches in town. I always get the War Pig! I love a good BLT, and this one is the best I've ever had. The roasted tomatoes and herb toasted bread brings the classic BLT to a whole new level. I've seriously ordered it almost every weekend since I've tried it. Do your tastebuds a huge favor and try one of their sandwiches. You won't be dissappointed.
E
Elizabeth W
1 contributions
Liked
• 11/30/25
• DoorDash order
Perfect roadtrip stop, not too expensive and was great quality ingredients that didn't make me feel icky after! I did think the portions would be a little larger because the other reviews said that they were massive. They were good size for the price. I would order again if I come through. The Smoke 2 Joints was pretty fire and my friend really liked The Oath.
L
Lindsay B
5 contributions
Liked
• 4/18/26
• DoorDash order
was told by Darrin, who workst here to try this place. he recommended the *NEW* The John popper I wasnt disappointed with my sanwhich at all but enjoyed the Pulled Pork & Pepper jack Quesadilla more, so delicious! The Cheese Bread Incident was perfect.
T
Tara C
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/20/23
• DoorDash order
Only received one of my three items. Luckily my dasher was kind enough to go back for the second two items-which hadn't even been made. The one sandwich we did receive came in a disastrous pile and was smothered in yellow mustard. Tried calling the number provided three times with no answer, was able to message my Dasher and have her relay the message for them to call me. Once we received the second (I believe the Oath?)sandwich it was very good, the cheese bread was okay. The Otherside did call me back, I was offered free drink tickets for the inconvenience. Not super impressed. 
C
Chad C
1 contributions
Liked
• 5/5/26
• DoorDash order
In Da Club was very delicious.Baby’s got Sauce was really flavorful.The Rick Reuben definitely needs some help. Bread was dryer than I thought it be, Nothing special about the meat,
