Urban Farmhouse consistently makes the best cheesecake. I honestly did not even like cheesecake until I had theirs. I order from them almost every week. The Peanut Butter and Jelly Cheesecake this week is my favorite flavor so far! A true Lancaster Gem!
C
Chelsea P
2 contributions
Loved
• 1/22/25
• DoorDash order
Creme brulee and cheesecake are my favorite desserts, so the fact that these flavors were combined together was absolutely unbelievable! The best cheesecake I've ever had! Not too sweet, the perfect balance of flavors and sweetness. The strawberry crunch cheesecake tasted exactly like the ice cream bar, and it was so good! I believe the hype and understand why these flavors are some of your best sellers and fan favorites 😊
S
Shea A
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
Loved
• today
• DoorDash order
Incredible cheesecake. Ordered 7 flavors today and was not disappointed. By far the most flavorful and fun choices! Try the cookie butter!
J
John N
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/30/26
• DoorDash order
The strawberry cheesecake was everything and more! I'm a big fan of the banana pudding and as soon as I saw it was a cheesecake flavor, I hopped on that! Honestly, it doesn't taste very good. I don't think it works? It's a little sour with the cream cheese taste, with the banana flavor didn't compliment each other. Idk I kept tasting sour. Didn't really taste banana-y. The crust had no taste to it, but the strawberry cheesecake crust/bottom tasted amazing! If it was me, I'd get the banana pudding that's not cheesecake, the cream/ sour taste threw everything off. The banana pudding cheesecake flavor made me lose my appetite. Not sure if maybe she ran out of ideas and had extra banana pudding and decided to add that flavor for national cheesecake day but it was not it.
B
Brianna D
6 contributions
Loved
• 7/29/25
• DoorDash review
All of the cheesecake is phenomenal. I would order again a million times over. Just a few favorites- apple pie, strawberry shortcake, cookie monster, PB&J, blueberry crumb, creme brulee, banana rumchata, Oreo, turtle!
