TheCalzone is always awesome ..one of the best in town! first time trying the Cheese (Personal 9") but since it was Pi Day I figured I had to and had to have a piece before I took a picture ..soooo good! and had to have a little taste of this delicious Cheese Cake before I took a pic and rated as well lol everything perfect! Thank You!
M
Margaret C
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/15/24
• DoorDash review
This was an unfortunate $20 purchase for a burned, cold 9-inch pizza. It was not even lukewarm. The crust was completely black on the edges and bottom, and large amounts of garlic were dropped in clumps randomly on the pizza and the basil was so overcooked it was black and inedible. Such a shame, because I have had great meals from Todaro's, but also really disappointing ones like this one.
M
M G
22 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/14/26
• DoorDash order
The pizzas had such a thin, overcooked crust it was like eating a charred cracker. There was barely any sauce or toppings, so they were very unfulfilling. I counted 5 pieces of pineapple on the entire pizza?! Are you rationing the customer to a ridiculously quantity? The ham was diced into tiny bits. I don't usually leave negative reviews, but this was the worst pizza we've had in a long time.
The calzones we ordered the other day were ok, but they also had very little toppings but tons of ricotta. We had to scoop it out and by the time we did that, the shell was flat. We won't be ordering pizzas again, because what you see is definitely not what you get!
R
Richard O
2 contributions
Loved
• 6/18/22
• DoorDash order
The Todara Special supreme was beyond epic! It was excellent!! An awesome balance of meat and veggies with the mushrooms, green peppers and red onions setting off the sausage and pepperoni. The garlic butter dipping sauce is surreal and the garlic knots are well worth it. This was my first time ordering from here with many to come in the future. Thumbs all the way up!!
S
Sara H
2 contributions
Loved
• 12/31/21
• DoorDash order
I travel a lot and make habit to find the best versions of foods. A good crust really makes a pizza and Todaro nails it. The basic cheese is perfect. You'd have to go to NY to get a better Brooklyn style slice
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Traditional Pizzas
Specialty Pizzas
Pizza by The Slice
Todaro Pizza Extras
Todaro Pizza Salads
Stuffed Pizza
Available in medium and large only. This pizza is a monster. It’s packed with mozzarella and the fillings of your choice, with a pizza crust on top forming a delicious pizza pocket. We say, why stuff the crust when you can stuff the whole pizza?
Calzones & Stromboli
What’s the difference between these two golden beauties? Basically, it’s three things, the shape, the cheeses and the texture. The calzone is a half moon shape, with a dome, starts with both mozzarella and ricotta cheeses inside and is more loosely packed with your extra toppings. The stromboli has more of a torpedo shape, without as much of a dome, starts with only mozzarella cheese and is overall denser than its calzone sister.
