Excellent pizza, definitely taste like Authentic Chicago pizza!!! Love it!
J
Jack S
13 contributions
Loved
• 5/10/26
• DoorDash order
Best pizza around. The Chicago deep dish is hands down the best pizza in the area. The New York is excellent but I gotta say it's a toss up between here and Fratelli's but it's definitely top three. Only issue I had is they don't seal the box and I feel like every company should do that for customer safety and security.
N
Nick M
3 contributions
Loved
• 4/1/26
• DoorDash review
It was so good, especially the Margarita with Pepperoni. The basil on it tastes so fresh. I would definitely order this again. There was so much left after too. For how it tasted it was a good price.
A
Andy T
120 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/11/26
• DoorDash order
Usually I like Two Cities New York BYO but this past time it was overcooked and cold. It reminded me of old Chuck E. Cheese pizza tonight which is TERRIBLE. Also their online DoorDash menu is confusing with its bake and cut options and they aren't explained ANYWHERE. Sometimes the New York Style pizza here is good, sometimes not. Sometimes really cheesy, sometimes not. Sometimes the crust is delicious and sometimes too hard and sometimes so soft you can't hold it up to eat it. Sometimes the slices are normal and sometimes so big one has to fold it to eat it. The quality control and consistency just isn't there. Also they offer toppings on specific pizzas that the do not offer in the topping choices on the build your own pizza options which is a real missed opportunity. When you order ham here also realize it is candian bacon and so so tough. I wish they would be consistent and improve.
S
Sheila L
Local Expert • 55 contributions
Liked
• 5/24/26
• DoorDash order
The meatballs are fabulous as always! The pizzas had good flavor, however, the cauliflower crust needs to be crispier --- even asking for it to be well done didn't quite get it there.
