We decided to open Wicked Pie Pizza in the booming downtown neighborhood of Puyallup, Washington, as lifelong pizza makers.
Curious passers-by peered into the abandoned music store months before we o…
Wicked Pie has become my favorite Pizza place. Wicked Pie in Puyallup never disappoints. I even tried a different pizza than I normally do, The Large The Puyallup. LOVED it! Thank you all from Wicked Pie. You are wonderful when we dine in, and a sure bet when we order out.
C
C R
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/17/26
• DoorDash review
50% the time we get a great amazing pizza at Wicked Pie Pizza in Puyallup. Great crust, tasty marinara sauce, and quality toppings with great flavor, just the right amount of cheese.
However, last July when my uncle was here we ordered our usuals and it fell flat of our expectations. I was embarrassed because I had told him how amazing the food was here and it was not that good. I threw away our left overs (we always eat our left overs).
The next time in September, I picked up a half cheese and the other half had sausage, mushroom and onion. We ate it at the concert in the park. It was so good and it met with approval with my Milan, Italian exchange student.
Almost a year later in May, we ordered the equal with sausage, pepperoni and ricotta and garlic. Extreme amount of garlic. Even though it was minced garlic, it was place in chunks on the pizza. It did not enhance the pizza. Way way too much garlic. Gross. Crust ok but not great, sauce ok, but nothing to say that makes this place stand out or makes you want to order from here. What happened to this place? It used to be amazing- like comparable to NYC Bleeker Street pizza amazing. Did they change staff?
L
Latoya H
4 contributions
Liked
• 5/14/26
• DoorDash order
The Chosen One pizza was good. The grinder was ok except they're could be more vegetables. The wings were disappointing! There were 7 bland wings for over $20. That's almost $3 a wing! Not worth it.
P
Priscilla B
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Liked
• 2/28/26
• DoorDash order
The marinara sauce tasted bitter and the garlic dipping sauce was basically a clove of garlic blended with a little blue cheese. The celery should been packaged separate as they were rubbery.
A
Angela M
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/13/25
• DoorDash order
The Large Mob Boss was not like picture. It was tiny pieces of meatballs and hardly not much on pizza. Felt like I ordered a vegetarian and for the price? Disappointed
