The Breaded Mushrooms had a really good flavor. The sauce, I think was horseradish, also had a good flavor. I thought it would be too hot but no. I even put some on the NY Famous Veggie Burger. I enjoyed the taste of the burger very much. I like my burgers well done but this was cooked little too long for my taste but I enjoyed it. When I order it again I will try to order with cheese and raw onion. I highly recommend both the Mushrooms and the Veggie Burger. I think you will be pleased.
N
Nichole D
2 contributions
Loved
• 4/8/26
• DoorDash order
I haven't had windmill in probably 20 years and they went above and beyond, even put a note in my food they told me they tried to fill my order exactly as I asked and they did. It was perfect and the food is absolutely amazing.! I would definitely order from them. Thank you so much. I do appreciate you if I'm stuck in a hotel my husband has died and I just needed something really really good to eat and you really came through. I will be ordering again. Bravo.
J
James S
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/4/26
• DoorDash order
I guess they were running out of french fries or something. But I ordered cheese fries and it was less than half a normal portion size. I've been getting cheese fries here for years. This was less than a handful of fries. 
S
Shelly D
1 contributions
Didn't like
• today
• DoorDash order
I've been eating windmill all my life, on and off but whenever I'm in town recently and pick up or get delivery, this location is just terrible. Couple of years ago I had an experience where it seemed really obvious it was probably the manager of this location causing a lot of the issues but I have no idea who the manager is these days. When a restaurant just deletes something they're out of (simple as a kid's hot dog and fries and especially at night when I might not have other options this late and without contacting me for any kind of replacement or even letting me know until the delivery was on its way}, gives you the kids size fries instead of normal, and cooks those fries just enough so they're warm and not frozen but have maybe 5 with barely crispy edges. it might be time to do a review.
:(
S
SEAN C
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
Liked
• 3/8/26
• DoorDash order
The Long Branch Windmill should go and retrain the Red Bank location on how to make food, the quality is sooo much better!! I even got ice with soda. The cheese fries are much crispy not soggy.
