this is my favorite pizza. one thing weve noticed is that the smaller sized pizzas taste better! i recommend getting a two 10s vs one 14, for example.
D
Darren C
Local Expert • 34 contributions
Loved
• 11/9/25
• DoorDash order
The 18" Build Your Own Pizza was outstanding. All of the people wasting their time and money with Sexton's should get Yellow Brick instead. Crust was fantastic. Plenty of cheese. Perfect amount of pepperoni. This place is immediately added to the hand-tossed rotation, 5/5*.
However -the Hot Knots were absolutely not what I was expecting. The description made it seem like they were garlic knots that they then bake again with some cheese. Instead, these were plain knots that were then tossed with some strange blend of spices. Absolutely inedible, and should be removed from the menu entirely.
N
Nick L
Local Expert • 72 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/14/24
• DoorDash order
Not near enough sauce on the pizza, and it was just sort of bland. Paid an extra 1.50 for garlic crust, and it just had italian seasoning and it was bad. probably won't order again.
A
Ashanti W
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/14/23
• DoorDash review
I love the food but I wish they had an option to add extra marinara sauce on the side since they charge you extra for it. I called the restaurant and told them I wanted extra, they said they would put it in my bag, but then my Dasher says they can't put it in my bag because it's an extra charge. If that's the case Can you please put the option for extra sauce on your menu? Especially since the portion they give you isn't even enough for the size of the calzone.
S
Stetson C
Local Expert • 20 contributions
Liked
• 12/16/23
• DoorDash order
Caprese Salad was a very small portion for 5 dollars.
