I have ordered from PIE PIZZA before & will continue to do so. The create your own pasta is WONDERFUL, always hot, great quality & quantity. Same with the create your own pizza. The Gelato PEACHES AND CREAM GELATO was DELICIOUS.
NO COMPLAINTS HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
J
Jesus M
24 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/20/25
• DoorDash order
CAESAR SIDE SALAD was pathetic compared to the picture. No croutons, pinch of lettuce and touch of cheese. Pizza is great but skip the salad for 5$
L
Londa H
Local Expert • 125 contributions
Loved
• 9/23/25
• DoorDash order
SMOKESTACK BRISKET SANDWICH The Taste was great the portion was wonderful the freshness delicious, I would order this again . 😋 LEMON PEPPER PARMESAN WINGS, Ialways ordered the wings they are delicious!!!
S
Sarah E
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/16/25
• DoorDash order
It's not delivery, it's.... wait, it actually is delivery.
The quality of this pizza is about on par with good frozen pizza. I was expecting a charred, blistered, bubbly crust-I did not get it. I expected melty, gooey cheese and browned toppings-I didn't get that either.
The CHEESE STICKS were essentially Little Caesar's cheese sticks, just much much smaller. The ISCHIA MARGHERITA had wilted basil strips that tasted like nothing and chewy, gummy mozzarella. The LINEAGE SUPREME was the best of the 3, but it wasn't really anything special either.
Overall, the pizza would have been 4 stars if it had been frozen and if I'd paid frozen prices for it. As it is, there's way better pizza in the Quad Cities for this price.
B
Brittany B
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/25/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered a 10 inch Italian sausage BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA. My pizza came with SO MANY BUBBLES! It was also misshappened and the crust was so thin that I have thicker envelopes that I get through the mail than this pizza crust. The bubbles took up more than half of multiple pizza slices that I had to eat around so I didn't really get what I paid for. The sauce and cheese was scarce as well. The one thing I liked was the Italian sausage that had a good amount of spice and flavor. Otherwise this pizza was not successful. I wish I had a pic to show just how many bubbles it had but I was starving so I just started eating without thinking of pictures.
