Bagel Supreme
4.5(2k+)•
DashPass•
Bakery•
Store Info
DashPass
4.5(2k+)•
$•Bakery
Bagels, Breakfast Sandwiches, Pancakes, French Toast, Waffles, Omelettes, Breakfast Wraps, Muffins & Baked, Hot Specialty Paninis, Salad Sandwich Selections, Boars Head Sandwiches, Fresh Salads, Hot S…
Full Menu
5:00 am - 2:10 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Meat, Egg, & Cheese Sandwich
$8.99
Dozen (12) Bagel (No Spread)
$17.25
Chicharron Omelette
$12.46
Nova Lox and Onion
$12.46
French Toast Platter
$12.46
Californian Wrap
$11.95
Reviews2k+ ratings • 30+ public reviews
4.5
of 5 stars
J
Janet G
7 contributionsLoved
• 9/29/22Have tried all the bagel stores in my area per Door Dash list...Bagel Supreme e is the best....Taylor ham is perfectly cooked...the sandwich is carefully made and one of the best corn muffins I have had in a very long time....Thank you..
R
Rivera R
2 contributionsLoved
• 10/4/21I order from here practically weekly their bagels are the best in Rutherford. They are very large and the cream cheese is very fresh cannot recommend this place enough.
D
Dawn V
2 contributionsLoved
• 6/26/26The smoothies were delicious and came in the cutest cans. The muffin was cut in 3 toasted with butter, absolutely perfect!
K
Kevin E
5 contributionsLoved
• 12/19/21The best Bagels in Northern Jersey!
I honestly went on a personal adventure to find the best bagels. After trying many and loving/ hating many I narrowed it down to the few best but over all this place had the best in my personal opinion.
Top 3
1. Bagel Supreme ( Rutherford, NJ)
2. Goldberg's Pompton Lakes ( Pompton Lakes, NJ)
3. Nicks Hot Bagels ( River Edge, NJ)
Honorable Mentioned below
Metro Bagels & Grill ( North Arlington, NJ)
Bob's Bagel ( Lyndhurst, NJ)
Bloomfield Best Bagels and Deli ( Bloomfield, NJ)
F
Fatima G
1 contributionsDidn't like
• 12/6/24Honey Turkey Sandwich does not have anything otherthan turkey! So dry!!
Tuna Salad Egg Salad Sandwich they send me tuna salad on a toast, not even toasted
I call to ask why, the lady explains I need to choose between tuna or egg, so pay attention its not what the name say!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Bagels
Breakfast Sandwiches
Lox Specials
Protein & Performance Bagels
Protein Shakes
A selection of our Protein Shakes, and their base size is 16oz.
City-sized Omelettes
Breakfast Wraps
Pancake, French Toast, Waffles and Combo Deals
The Carb-UP Menu
Supreme Signature Line Up
Salad Sandwich Selections
Served with chips and pickle.
Lunch Wraps
Subs
Hot Specialty Panini
All hot specialty paninis served with chips and pickle.
Boar's Head Sandwiches
Served with chips and pickle.
Fresh Salads
The Lunch Box
All lunch boxes served with chips and pickle.
Refreshers
All Refreshers are only 50 calories with 80mg of caffeine per 12oz.