I ordered about 5 cookies and 1 brownie. Let me start off with this box did not last 24 hours. They were all so GOOD. My favorite had to be the s'mores it was filled with marshmallow and it had chunks of chocolate chips and graham cracker bits. I was so impressed with this cookie. My other favorite was the chocolate mint cookie as well! It literally tasted like a thin mint cookie and I wish I had ordered more! Overall tasty and great! I will be ordering from this place for my cookie cravings!
J
JAY Q
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
Loved
• 9/14/25
• DoorDash order
These cookies are an absolute treat! They’re excellent quality, with a rich, flavorful taste that keeps me coming back for more. The texture and flavor are super consistent from one batch to the next, which makes them really reliable compared to other brands. On top of that, the great packaging keeps them fresh and presentable, whether I’m enjoying them at home or sharing with friends. For the price, they’re a great value—you get both indulgence and dependability in every bite.
K
Karen D
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/23/25
• DoorDash order
Crisp exterior and chewy center. Favorites were peanut butter and double chocolate chunk. We bought these to try the red velvet cookies that are available only for Valentine's Day. They were missing the cream cheese filling featured in all the ads. We cracked open both and no cream cheese filling or flavor so this cookie was very bland.
S
Shane W
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/1/25
• DoorDash order
The cookies were all smushed together in the box so they were falling apart and they were all really oily. It also seems like some of them weren't cooked fully through. I know it's the end of the night but if you're advertising as a late night cookie chain, I'd expect better quality than seemingly having sat out all day and then squished in a box. I'll likely skip ordering from here again.
S
Sydney B
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/5/22
• DoorDash order
The standard cookies are smaller than expected. Delivered warm. Vegan birthday cookie is a favorite! 2nd time ordering from Insomnia via DoorDash and each time delivery was late. Delivery time is not accurate. Arrived 25 minutes late and shop did not answer phone. According to DoorDash status, the cookies were being prepared for 45 minutes. Yet it estimated 30 minute delivery from when I submitted my order.
