Due to our small kitchen, we can only offer orders of up to 7 pizzas through doordash.
If you are looking to make an order for 8 pizzas or more, for a date in the future, please email the restaurant …
Incredible pizza - probably the best New York style in east bay. Love the mini pepperonis and size. Caesar didnt have enough dressing nor anything by to write home about when there are such good salad places . Meatballs are out of this world - true Italian style and fresh sauce.
E
Erin B
4 contributions
Loved
• 6/12/25
• DoorDash order
I've only tasted Mama's Boy Pizza twice (I must admit, twice in less than a week ).. yes...it was that good. I typically wait to review until I've tried a new place a handful of times over at least a month or two and at least 1x in the restaurant however the pizza, Chopped Salad and homemade Ranch were so good I'm confident saying that this is the best NY style pizza and one of the very best pizza joints in the Bay Area. The chopped salad was fantastic, extremely fresh lettuces, the ceci beans (aka chickpeas), red wine vinegrette were the perfect compliment to the lovely variety of lettuces. An addition of crumbled feta cheese in lieu of the finely shaved parm would be amazing but it is delicious just as is. I typically order a small vegetarian pie for myself and a medium or large meat pie for my partner but Mama's Boy 20" pizzas are so big and filling we went for a half and half and we both had leftovers. Tip to perfectly reheat pizza, heat oven to 400F, put cast irin pan or pizza stone in oven while preheating, when tempreture is set, place pie in oven for 5 minutes & you'll have a perfectly heated slice that has a crisp not limp crust!
My only complaint when ordering delivery online there isn't an option to select one of their pizza combinations as a half pie so I was instructed to select a 20" Cheese Pie and then select my desired toppings for either the 1st half, 2nd half and/or whole pie. The only down side to ordering this way is that even if you mirror each half as one of their menu item pies (i.e.veggie & supreme) the pie ends up costing substantially more than the cost of any of their menu item pies. Hopefully, this can be fixed to enable ordering of menu item pies as a 1/2 pie without paying an extra $20+ to the cost of their menu item pies. Even a $5.00 flat rate charge for a half and half order of menu item pies w be preferable. Whether eating in or ordering delivery, Mama's Boy Pizza is a must try!
G
Gustavo H
Emerging Expert • 43 contributions
Loved
• 1/26/26
• DoorDash order
This is the best most delicious vegetarian pepperoni and vegetarian sausage pizza EVER! Mouth watering, thin crust * I recommend checking the crispy box if you don't want it to wilt in your hand, it doesn't make it rock hard but it stands up a little more, if you like it soft , keep as is.
The ingredients are so fresh tasting so flavorful really just consistently mouth watering!
L
Lauren S
2 contributions
Loved
• 1/4/26
• DoorDash order
Best damn NY-style pizza in the bay. As an easy coast transplant living here for almost 10 years, this is the spot I've been searching for.
The 20" Burrata is incredible. $50 for 20" inches is insane, and yet I pay it like an addict.
10/10, would go broke ordering pizza again.
T
Tim S
3 contributions
Loved
• 4/26/26
• DoorDash order
i got the 20" Pesto and it was amazing, the crust was the right rigidity that you could fold or eat flat, the toppings all complimented each other. i also got a Large side of Burrata (6oz) whichwe drisled on the top.
