Papa Johns Pizza
4.4(3k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.4(3k+)•
$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
10:00 am - 12:45 amFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Create Your Own Pizza
$10.39
•88% (45)
Buy 1, get 1 free
Pepperoni Pizza
$10.59
•78% (19)
Buy 1, get 1 free
Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza
$24.74
•100% (14)
Cheese Pizza
$10.39
•84% (33)
Buy 1, get 1 free
Super Hawaiian Pizza
$16.79
•100% (11)
Unsauced Boneless Wings
$11.49
Reviews3k+ ratings • 10+ public reviews
4.4
of 5 stars
S
Sammy L
Emerging Expert • 16 contributionsLoved
• 11/1/24Ah, Papa John's in Valley Stream — the place where culinary dreams are cooked up right between the strip mall parking lot and the discount nail salon. But let’s talk about the food, shall we?
The cheese pizza? Actually, quite the surprise. A slice of satisfaction! The crust had that perfect bite, a lovely crisp edge that could almost make you forget the industrial tiling under your feet. And the cheese — rich, gooey, just the right balance of creamy and salty. I mean, it’s not exactly Naples, but it’s like the pizza really wants you to *believe* it could be.
And then, oh, the garlic sauce. This wasn’t just any garlic sauce; this was garlic sauce that leaned into its garlic-ness, unapologetically. The kind of sauce that boldly says, *"I belong with this pizza, and I am not subtle."* Pair it together, and you’ve got yourself a garlicky, savory masterpiece in a plastic cup.
Then, dessert. The chocolate chip cookie. Freshly warmed, with melty chocolate that made you pause. A sweet, chewy treasure that almost — almost — made you forget you were eating it off a plastic table under the fluorescent glare of a Valley Stream strip mall.
In short, Papa John’s: where the pizza is far better than the ambiance would dare to admit.
R
Ruth V
1 contributionsDidn't like
• 9/6/23I spent two dollars on two sauces and the container was barley full some parts of the pizza was burnt I also asked for exta sauce on my pizza but its mostly just cheese and barley any sauce. Horrible service
C
Chadmar B
1 contributionsLiked
• 12/15/25Good taste, topping wasn't a lot on the pizza, you could count the amount.
V
Varvara N
1 contributionsLoved
• 1/30/25
really goooooooooooood but please fry the pineapples too (on top lf pizza) bc they taste like you took them right from the can and just put them straight on pizza;((
K
Komal S
3 contributionsDidn't like
• 6/6/25Not baked properly and less vegiiesput on in Garden Fresh Pizza o
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store