For nearly 20 years, Cincinnati pizza has been a standard!
In 2001, Jim Thompson established Lucy Blue as a late-night pizza storefront at 12th and Walnut in Cincinnati's Over the Rhine neighborhood. …
The Buffalo Chicken pizza is the BEST in Cincinnati! The celery was an interesting cruchy twist! The crust is INCREDIBLE! The Lucy's Homemade Ranch is better than any Ranch I've had! The Classic Caprese was not for me, but I am looking forward to trying something else. DEFINITELY will be back!!!
K
Kellen M
6 contributions
Loved
• 5/7/24
• DoorDash order
Lucy Blue's nails it once again!! Lucy's Mexican Pizza was our choice for 'taco Tuesday'. We decided to try the Bread Sticks so we could try the Lucy's Pizza Sauce (mild) and the Lucy's Pizza Sauce (original). The original was a little spicier. The mild had a good homemade taste, not sweet. The Italian Salad and Balsamic Vinaigrette is big enough for two people to share with lots of meat and toppings.
K
Kellen M
6 contributions
Loved
• 5/7/24
• DoorDash review
We may have a slight addiction to Lucy's!! This is the 3rd night we've ordered in the past 4! The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is the BEST in the tri-state! The homemade sauce is better than our own! We tried the Mexican Pizza tonight and it is equally as good as the Buffalo! The homemade ranch is better than steak house style. We love everything we've tried so far and look forward to trying EVERYTHING!!!!!
L
Lisa A
Local Expert • 14 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/19/25
• DoorDash order
I wanted to love this pizza but....
The pizzas had good flavor, although the toppings on the supreme were sparse, nothing like the advertised photos. Also, the toppings are pretty far away from the edge, definitely not edge to edge which is what I prefer. Both crusts were very thin and the edges were tough. The ranch tastes good but the cups are too small to dip into, and for the price I expected a larger portion.
A
Ashhar I
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/2/25
• DoorDash order
The Greek pizza was overdone and burned to the point that you could only eat half the slice. It was hard enough that you couldn't even fold the thin slices. The taste is beyond bland now. Really would like a refund.
