I couldn't wait to taste these coconut cupcakes! (That's why there's only 2 in the photo) I've never found coconut cakes or cupcakes as good as my homemade, but these are spot on!!! Tasty buttercream frosting and moist cake with shredded coconut. Even my husband loved them! He doesn't care much for cupcakes because they're not "my homemade" but he also ate 2 cupcakes in one sitting! I'm now a fan of Susie Cakes :)
M
Maika C
4 contributions
Loved
• 4/29/26
• DoorDash order
Delicious 😋! The portions are large, their 2 slices are enough for our family of 4. My favorite is the chocolate cake which is an amazing combination of light, chocolate, and rich. The carrot cake is also fantastic. The butterscotch filling is to die for. The cookies are also a win!
M
Miriam P
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Didn't like
• 1 day ago
• DoorDash order
Key Lime Pie Slice and Lemon Poppyseed Loaf were good flavor and texture and price point.
I have ordered off and on over the years and while the size of the 2 Specialty Cake Slices is the same, the quality felt lower.
Carrot cake tasted one note and collapsed into a wet pile of mush once transferred onto a plate. Needs citrus to add brightness and a better balance of wet/dry ingredients. The cakes have always been very sweet but used to have density, fluffiness, and standout flavors.
Strawberries and cream limited time cake was too much cream to fruit ratio, especially because it was a heavy fresh whipping cream frosting with high fat content that was actively breaking down inside and on top of the cake, doing a similar soggy pile of dairy separating against fruit that was pretty unappetizing. While the strawberries were good and creaminess is also great, mouth feel was like day old tres leches so saturated with liquid that it has lost its structure and is starting to "turn."
K
Kirra H
Emerging Expert • 19 contributions
Loved
• 5/15/25
• DoorDash order
Always amazing! We appreciated the note explaining that the requested "writing" on the cupcakes was unavailable, and instead of requesting a refund from DoorDash, the store included an extra cupcake to my order of 8 Box Cupcake Assortment. These are my absolute favorite cupcakes in the area and their full cakes are fantastic, too.
K
Katherine V
12 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/20/23
• DoorDash order
Cake slice was SMALL. And 2 different cake slices were significantly different size from eachother. One slice was child size. Too expensive of a cake to have such small slices. Also taste was bland, not really worth the calories
